DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
wows forum
HTML https://wows.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: General Discussion
*****************************************************
#Post#: 13--------------------------------------------------
Examine replays - about tactics, mistakes.
By: wows Date: December 27, 2021, 10:39 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Mostly people show replays where they get a good score.
In every such extraordinary replay is easy to manetion which
mistakes the person did. Because there are always mistakes and
can always be done better.
And it is mentally very healthy to talk always about both
mistakes and not mistakes. for example the famous Buddha made
msitakes, Einstein as well, all your idols make mistakes,
everybody does. If you cannot see the mistakes but others can
then you should practice to analyze things in life. Sooner or
later you will gain ability to see clearly every detail about
everything. This topic here helps you to develope such skill in
the life. We take a replay and talk about it and we definitely
mention mistakes about every replay. Mistakes are normal and
healthy but we also talk about related other aspects. We learn
if there is something to learn. Very often there is nothing to
learn in the videos where a person make an enormously high
result. If you haven't analized anything in your life before
then it is very hard to believe that you have any interest or
knowledge about the topic.
I post first random replay with screenshots here. And i can talk
hundreds of pages/hours about that random replay and about any
other replay. We don't hurry with the analyzing. And nobody of
us are right or wrong here when giving thoughts about replays.
Speak openly, share your ideas about tactics and other things.
Al lthat makes you a better and more sophisticated human. Yes,
it makes you also a better player, but it does not really matter
how good you are in the entertainment games. So, if you learn
something here and become better in a game then fine but this is
not the ultimate goal.
I post first random replay and add my first comments later.
Replay:
HTML https://replayswows.com/replay/149100
#Post#: 14--------------------------------------------------
Re: Examine replays - about tactics, mistakes.
By: wows Date: December 27, 2021, 10:40 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Adding some screenshots.
So, we can start to analyze those screenshots. Which thoughts do
you get by watching them?
On the "Credits And XP" picture you see that with a premium
account a person earns a positive amount of credits. On the left
column you see that if there wasn't a premium account then the
person would have lost credits. The result would have been minus
-7k credits. So, having a premium account is a must if you want
to play Tier 10 standard ships and not to bankrupt. That is the
first thing to notice on that screenshot and realize about the
game business. If you go futher with your thoughts from here
then you realize that being in the clan is quite important in
this game because it reduces expences and helps other way. You
see on the same screenshot phrases "Clan bonus". Those phrases
help a lot a new player. There are also some Signals/Flags/Camos
that can make the expenses lower but it is not so easy to get
those signals and things. The game creator has porposly made the
game economy such that one would need a premium account. So,
when i started to play a year ago then my first thought was to
create a clan and buy a premium account on the Christmas time.
It is a longer topic what else to do after creating an empty
clan. So, initially i added such thought about that screenshot.
I will add many other thoughts later about that screenshots and
add other screenshots. We will talk endlessly about that replay
and any other replay. If we feel we don't want to analize so
much then we won't. My main idea is that you should be able to
talk about anything in life from many perspectives. About any
replay, about any opinion, about any truth. That is part of the
life.
Happy talking.
#Post#: 39--------------------------------------------------
Re: Examine replays - about tactics, mistakes.
By: wows Date: January 9, 2022, 7:47 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Let's look at the first attached image from the previous post,
that one:
HTML https://wows.createaforum.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=5.0;attach=3;image
Which thoughts you get if you look at it?
I give some my random thoughts to warm up. On the alley team you
see that there are TOP 4 players all together TOP 1 because they
all got the same experience amount which is 900 to 1000. There
is no difference if one get 995 points and the other gets 992
points, but there is a difference if one gets 995 points and the
other gets 600 points. Therefore all TOP 4 alley ships are
actually all together TOP 1 and noone of those 4 played better
from each other, they played equally. On position 5 we got a
player with 800 points which i also almost the same like TOP 4,
only 10% difference. But let's say he was TOP 2. Last 2 players
made 600-700 which puts them to TOP 3. This is the first glance
to the alley team to make real TOP 3. In general all the alley
team players made almost equal perfomance getting 700-1000
points. So, there were no better player in that team actually.
But on the enemy team the TOP 3 is totally different. We talk
about that and other issues in the future. Feel free to join
with talk.
#Post#: 175--------------------------------------------------
Re: Examine replays - about tactics, mistakes.
By: wows Date: August 3, 2022, 10:29 am
---------------------------------------------------------
The previous replay shows the enemy BB to make 5 kills and other
2 team members the remaining 2 kills. There really is no skills
involved with BBs. Enemies just have to show broad side to the
BB and the RNG must bless the BB bulelts to make detonations and
citadel hits and the enemies be quite low in HP at that moment.
That is no kind of skill but an occacional luck. Some people
believe that 5 kills involve some kind of knowledge and
expertize but it doesn't. Aiming matters 70%, broadside holding
20%, prioritizing DD targets 10%. There is no need to talk about
positioning because most times all primitive ships swim to the
same position. If one thinks that right timing for setting
radars is a skill then it is not. One pushes it just when he
arrives to the cap circle, that is elementary and not a skil lto
be mentioned. So, mainly aiming. And no need to talk about
knowledge or Skills. In that replay those 5 kills didn't came
because of some advanced moves and actions. It came because
enemies showed broad side and bullets detonated well by RNG and
aiming was fine.
#Post#: 293--------------------------------------------------
Re: Examine replays - about tactics, mistakes.
By: wows Date: August 26, 2022, 1:03 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Todays replay
HTML https://replayswows.com/replay/165779
We can talk about such topics incl others:
1. clockwise rotation around a small island is infinitive
therefore one of the 2 ships should change the direction to
counter-clockwise.
2. Yoshinos very far positioning. It was good because he
survived until the end. Unfortunately he didn't know how to do
the clockwise thing.
I suggest that all replays should have something educational and
one rude rule also that there should not be any egoic result in
the battle. Max 2 kills allowed for the poster, otherwise
denied. When i make those "allowed, denied" rules i hope you
understand what i mean by those. Wows community is denied
obviously, and you undrstand that. So, try not to post replays
with some kind of 4+ kills.
#Post#: 294--------------------------------------------------
Re: Examine replays - about tactics, mistakes.
By: wows Date: August 27, 2022, 2:41 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=wows link=topic=5.msg293#msg293 date=1661537013]
1. clockwise rotation around a small island is infinitive
therefore one of the 2 ships should change the direction to
counter-clockwise.
[/quote]
So, there is a small island and the minimap shows that the enemy
behind the island looks in clockwise moving direction. Then
there is no point to chase him with the same clockwise direction
on the othe side of the island because his moving speed is equal
to yours.
In this video Yoshino didn't take that thing into consideration
and started and endless chasing around an island which wasted
time and battle ended with a loss.
There is no intension to say any complains, only to educate
everyone, including me.
#Post#: 329--------------------------------------------------
Re: Examine replays - about tactics, mistakes.
By: wows Date: August 31, 2022, 12:14 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Related picture of the clockwork idea.
Because the CV's nose looks left and he moves slow backwards (to
the right) so the BB goes meet him from the right so the CV
can't escape.
Simple ideas but many makes mistakes about the clockwork idea
even in the Gold league.
Of course if emotions take our then intellect fades. But if you
read some theoretical turtorials first liek this one here then
very likely you don't make clockwork-mistakes.
HTML https://i.imgur.com/EWLoV9Y.png
#Post#: 531--------------------------------------------------
Re: Examine replays - about tactics, mistakes.
By: wows Date: September 23, 2022, 4:52 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
We can post some days Replays where i get TOP 1 in Gold league.
And anyone can now post replays with 2+ kills for the next few
days. But after that it is not allowed again anymore. Also won't
be allowed to post stats information. al legoic/rasitic things
wil lbe prohibited again.
--
Results, TOP-listing:
HTML https://i.imgur.com/ySy4uZV.png
Replay and screenshots:
HTML https://replayswows.com/replay/167538
For stats i made a screenshot of today's/23/09 battles. As you
see on 22/09 the Ranked WR was 18% and on 23/09 62% and your
favourite overall WR is 42%. As i remember i was 1 times as TOP
1 among those ca 16 battles.
Also i did 1 Trolling battle as a team member requested. In all
battles including the TOP 1 i did the Mild Tactics Package which
i have described little bit in another topic. It means mainly
that capping is not allowed for DDs.
Usually i get more TOP 1 battles than this time, but i
personally don't care how many times i get or which stats i or
anyone has. But let's see some days how many TOP ! results i get
per evenings. Because it was in another topic as an idea. and
there was also said that i don't get TOP 1 usually. So, we can
test such claims. But i don't do such challenge for longer than
few days, and after that we again prohibit replays with 2+
kills.
HTML https://i.imgur.com/5sWC0kS.png
#Post#: 549--------------------------------------------------
Re: Examine replays - about tactics, mistakes.
By: wows Date: September 24, 2022, 9:10 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Today's TOP 1 battles.
This is the 2nd battle todat with TOP 1. I make around 12
battles in total and usually i get ca 3 times TOP 1.
The below example battle does again the Mild Package with no
capping, and also the Universal torps 2 times which we described
somewhere. 1st time it fails but you clearly see how the waiting
and aiming looks like with the Universals, the 2nd time it
succeeds. So, 2 special tactics from our future Wikipedia.
It feels very wrong to post battles with 3+ kills and al lthose
stats so i hope we end that soon.
We should speak somewhere why peopel are afraid to talk like "He
does this and that" instead of directly asking from the person.
--
HTML https://i.imgur.com/7sPEbgb.png
Replay and screenshots:
HTML https://replayswows.com/replay/167586
#Post#: 550--------------------------------------------------
Re: Examine replays - about tactics, mistakes.
By: wows Date: September 24, 2022, 9:46 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Battle number 4 was TOP 1 aswell like number 2.
In this battle i went straight to kill the enemy Cv and
succeeded. You do such Cv-mission with the Mild and Extreme
Package quite often.
Educational point was i nthe chat. I was threatened to be
reported.
I think the reporter was an enemy CV BB who i killed. This is
another example of wows community and its reporting
system/mentality or in shor "example of reporting".
If such threatning an humor then it does not sound funny because
abused reporting system is connected to racism and created
financial lost and suicides. It sounds like "i will murder you".
Doesn't sound funny. But this is how a racist community does.
--
Replay and images:
HTML https://replayswows.com/replay/167593
HTML https://i.imgur.com/qDINOXO.png
HTML https://i.imgur.com/76ITB3o.png
HTML https://i.imgur.com/rka6eAR.png
*****************************************************
DIR Next Page