DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
WebWar
HTML https://webwar.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: Ιστορία κ&#...
*****************************************************
#Post#: 20154--------------------------------------------------
Η κηδεία του &
#931;τρατηγού Μ`
0;ρουσίλοφ
By: Long Knives 88 Date: January 7, 2016, 4:54 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Oρθοδοξία,
Κομμουνισμa
2;ς
και
Στρατοκρατ^
3;α
Brusilov’s funeral in March 1926 revealed the attempts of the
Soviet military establishment to co-opt certain aspects of his
military glory. In the death announcement in Pravda on March 18,
1926, Kliment Voroshilov wrote the following:
The workers and peasants of the Soviet Union will not forget A.
A. Brusilov. In their memory, his image will be surrounded by a
bright halo, as a commander of the old army who was able to
understand the significance of the social transformation that
was occurring, and to elevate comprehension of the enthusiasm
for the revolutionary defense of the Republic of Workers and
Peasants.
Voroshilov argued that Brusilov would “live on” in the memory of
workers and peasants, and in this way gain immortality in a
Soviet civic context. The article also noted that the
Revvoensovet would arrange for a personal pension for the
Brusilov family and would pay funeral expenses. Brusilov was
thus embraced as a member of the Soviet establishment who would
be buried with official Soviet military honors.
Brusilov’s obituary recalled his connection to the Tsarist past.
He was described as “one of the most outstanding commanders of
the Russian army,” and it was noted that, “the name of Brusilov
is connected to the summer offensive of 1916 that led to the
breakthrough at Lutsk.”
The official state funeral of Brusilov accommodated his status
as a World War I hero and a Tsarist officer as well as his
position as a Soviet military official. The funeral was to take
place in an Orthodox cemetery, yet Voroshilov had suggested that
participating in the “revolutionary defense” of the nation was
the best way to commemorate Brusilov’s memory.
On the day of the funeral, a military honor guard, including a
company of infantry, a
squadron of cavalry, and a half-battery of artillery, arrived at
Brusilov’s home to accompany the funeral procession to
Novodevichii Cemetery. The delegation from Revvoensovet laid a
wreath on the coffin that was inscribed: “To an honest
representative of the old generation, who placed his battle
experience at the service of the USSR and the Red Army. To A.A.
Brusilov from the Revvoensovet.”
Yet Revvoensovet’s wreath was not the only decoration on
Brusilov’s coffin. The casket was also covered with “wreaths of
white flowers with ribbons of the order of St. George.” An
article in a Russian émigré newspaper noted with satisfaction:
“This was very likely the first time after the October
Revolution that St. George ribbons appeared openly on the
streets of Moscow."
Brusilov’s military successes in the Tsarist period were
publicly acknowledged, and the procession was allowed to display
both his Tsarist and Soviet honors. He was buried in 1926
explicitly as a military hero of both the pre-revolutionary and
revolutionary eras.
The Soviet troops accompanied Brusilov’s coffin to the gates of
the Novodevichii
Cemetery. There, the procession halted and three Soviet military
officials Aleksandr Egorov, (representing Revvoensovet), Semion
Budennyi, (representing the People’s Commissariat of Military
and Naval Affairs) and G. Gai (representing the Frunze Military
Academy) gave formal speeches about Brusilov’s contribution to
the Soviet military. Although the Soviet government organized a
state funeral, Voroshilov did not attend; Brusilov was valued by
the Soviet state, but was not honored by the top Soviet military
official.
G. Gai said, “Sleep peacefully outstanding general. Your
victorious saber, covered with laurels, is now in trustworthy
hands.” Gai thus publicly identified the Red Army as the
legitimate heir to the Tsarist army. Brusilov’s success in World
War I would be followed by the heroism and victory of the Red
Army.
The coffin was then taken inside Novodevichii monastery, but
Egorov, Budennyi and the Soviet troops remained standing at
attention outside the gates. Gai, along with Brusilov’s
relatives and friends accompanied the coffin to the grave. At
the graveside, relatives and friends gave speeches that were not
for Soviet public consumption; one speech expressed gratitude to
Brusilov “in the name of the Slavonic peoples, for his battle
against the Austro-Hungarian army." Another funeral oration
celebrated Brusilov’s relationship with rank and file Russian
soldiers. “The simple Russian soldier remembered his
father-commander and forgetting himself, through a truly noble
awakening, brought his labor to his father-commander.”
Both of these speeches demonstrate the persistence of unofficial
and non-Soviet
remembrances of World War I. Soviet ideology explicitly rejected
the notion that the
significance of the war was national liberation for Slavs;
likewise the official narratives of the war almost unanimously
condemned the Tsarist officer corps for its brutality towards
the “simple Russian soldier.” The memory of Brusilov as a
paternalistic and benevolent father-commander who could awaken
the soldiers to loyalty and noble labor was a subversive reading
of Brusilov’s life in the Soviet context. While Soviet officials
took great care to prevent these ideas from being expressed in
print as part of the official report of Brusilov’s funeral, they
nonetheless gave Brusilov’s friends and relatives the time and
space to remember him and the war in this most unofficial way.
After the speeches, the priest completed short prayers and the
funeral service ended with the singing of the words “eternal
memory” three times as Brusilov’s coffin was lowered into the
grave. Outside the cemetery, Budennyi gave a signal and soldiers
fired off a three shot salvo after each repetition of “eternal
memory.” Brusilov’s widow noted that this ritual took place
“exactly as in old times.” The Soviet army thus actively
participated in a religious-military tradition from
pre-revolutionary times in honor of Brusilov.
The remarkably hybrid nature of this ceremony and the active
cooperation between
Soviet officials and the church reveals the complicated
relationship of the Soviet government toward Brusilov’s military
achievements as a Tsarist general. Because Brusilov supported
the Soviet state, his glorious military career could be
celebrated both as a Soviet career but also on its own terms as
a reflection of an honorable Tsarist career. Because Brusilov
passed his “laurel covered saber” to the Soviet state, in fact,
he had to be recognized as an outstanding Tsarist general who
had brought honor to the Tsarist military in an otherwise
disastrous war. Brusilov’s legacy of Tsarist military success
was so valued by the Soviet military establishment that it
allowed Brusilov to be buried as a Tsarist general, with the
ribbons of the order of St. George in full sight, and in an
Orthodox cemetery in accordance with full Orthodox rites. They
even participated in the Tsarist military tradition of a gun
salvo at the moment of interment at the end of the Orthodox
funeral service. Like the World War I exhibit in the Military
History Museum, the Brusilov funeral demonstrates the
persistence of notions of Tsarist military valor in Soviet
discourse of the 1920s.
#Post#: 20167--------------------------------------------------
Re: Η κηδεία το`
5; Στρατηγού Μ
προυσίλοφ
By: mistermax Date: January 7, 2016, 8:09 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Με την
εξισωση του
κομμουνισμ_
9;υ
με ναζισμο
που
επιχειρει η
εε, θα
οδηγησει
τους
νεοναζι, που
πληθαινουν,
να
ερωτευοντα_
3;
τον Μαρξ, τον
Λενιν και
τον Σταλιν! :D :D
:D
#Post#: 20169--------------------------------------------------
Re: Η κηδεία το`
5; Στρατηγού Μ
προυσίλοφ
By: Long Knives 88 Date: January 7, 2016, 8:14 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=mistermax link=topic=2223.msg20167#msg20167
date=1452175784]
Με την
εξισωση του
κομμουνισμ_
9;υ
με ναζισμο
που
επιχειρει η
εε, θα
οδηγησει
τους
νεοναζι, που
πληθαινουν,
να
ερωτευοντα_
3;
τον Μαρξ, τον
Λενιν και
τον Σταλιν! :D :D
:D
[/quote]
δεν το βλέπω
κακό να
θαυμάζει
κάποιος Ε/Σ
τα Αντρικά
Ιδανικά που
εκπροσωπού`
3;ε
η Σοβιετική
Ένωση.
#Post#: 20175--------------------------------------------------
Re: Η κηδεία το`
5; Στρατηγού Μ
προυσίλοφ
By: Αρχιφα
σίστας Dat
e: January 7, 2016, 8:28 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=mistermax link=topic=2223.msg20167#msg20167
date=1452175784]
Με την
εξισωση του
κομμουνισμ_
9;υ
με ναζισμο
που
επιχειρει η
εε, θα
οδηγησει
τους
νεοναζι, που
πληθαινουν,
να
ερωτευοντα_
3;
τον Μαρξ, τον
Λενιν και
τον Σταλιν! :D :D
:D
[/quote]
Στην Ελλάδα
πάντως
μόνιμα οι
κομουνιστέ`
2;
θα
θεωρούνται
ήρωες και
αγωνιστές
δυστυχώς...
#Post#: 20176--------------------------------------------------
Re: Η κηδεία το`
5; Στρατηγού Μ
προυσίλοφ
By: Long Knives 88 Date: January 7, 2016, 8:35 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Pepe the Frog link=topic=2223.msg20175#msg20175
date=1452176895]
Στην Ελλάδα
πάντως
μόνιμα οι
κομουνιστέ`
2;
θα
θεωρούνται
ήρωες και
αγωνιστές
δυστυχώς...
[/quote]
Mε τους
κομμουνιστ^
1;ς
συμβαίνει
το περίεργο.
Όταν
αντιπολιτεa
3;ονται
είναι
κλαμμένα
μουνιά, όταν
κυβερνάνε
γίνονται
υπεργαμάτο_
3;
άντρακλες.
Οπότε οι
μόνοι
κομμουνιστ^
1;ς
που μπορεί
και που
πρέπει να
εκτιμάει
ένας Ε/Σ,
είναι αυτοί
που
κυβέρνησαν.
Εδώ στην
Ελλάδα δεν
κυβέρνησαν
άρα
γαμιούνται.
#Post#: 20177--------------------------------------------------
Re: Η κηδεία το`
5; Στρατηγού Μ
προυσίλοφ
By: Long Knives 88 Date: January 7, 2016, 8:47 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Oι Κόκκινοι
Κοζάκοι
στρατηγοί
του Ρώσικου
εμφυλίου
πάντως
είχαν όλοι
και γαμώ τα
μουστάκια
Semyon Budyonny
HTML http://victory.sokolniki.com/EditorFiles/image/Material/f4e3e9a81f003c1bfe16605e29e7f24e.jpg
HTML https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/3c/SM-Budyonny-01.jpg/150px-SM-Budyonny-01.jpg
Sergey Kamenev
HTML http://i783.photobucket.com/albums/yy111/mrmental/Kamenev_02.jpg
Oka Gorodovikov
HTML https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/7b/Oka_Gorodovikov.jpg
HTML http://historum.com/members/lionmaster-albums-radom2-picture4244-1073-1072-1089-1072-1085-1075-1086-1088-1086-1076-1086-1074-1080-1082-1086-1074.jpg
Kι ένα
ευχαριστώ
στον
κόκκινο
αταμάνο
Νικιφόρ
Γκριγκόριε`
6;
που έσωσε το
1919 την
Ουκρανία
από τον
αγγλο-γαλλο-&#
946;ενιζελικό
επεκτατισμa
2;
HTML https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/49/Ataman_Nikifor_Grigoriev_1919.jpg/242px-Ataman_Nikifor_Grigoriev_1919.jpg
#Post#: 20178--------------------------------------------------
Re: Η κηδεία το`
5; Στρατηγού Μ
προυσίλοφ
By: Αρχιφα
σίστας Dat
e: January 7, 2016, 9:10 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Long Knives 88 link=topic=2223.msg20177#msg20177
date=1452178072]
Kι ένα
ευχαριστώ
στον
κόκκινο
αταμάνο
Νικιφόρ
Γκριγκόριε`
6;
που έσωσε το
1919 την
Ουκρανία
από τον
αγγλο-γαλλο-&#
946;ενιζελικό
επεκτατισμa
2;
[/quote]
Είσαι
σίγουρος
ότι δεν
είσαι
κομουνιστή`
2;
έτσι; ???
#Post#: 20179--------------------------------------------------
Re: Η κηδεία το`
5; Στρατηγού Μ
προυσίλοφ
By: Long Knives 88 Date: January 7, 2016, 9:35 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Pepe the Frog link=topic=2223.msg20178#msg20178
date=1452179421]
Είσαι
σίγουρος
ότι δεν
είσαι
κομουνιστή`
2;
έτσι; ???
[/quote]
Πουτινικός
είμαι. Και αν
δεν υπήρχε
το 1919 ο
αταμάνος
Γκριγκόριε`
6;,
δε θα
υπήρχαν πια
Ρώσοι στην
Κριμαία, και
δε θα
μπορούσε
σήμερα η
Ρωσία να
υπερασπιστ^
9;ί
τα ιστορικά
εδάφη της.
Ο
Βλαδίμηρος
παρεμπιπτό_
7;τως
ανήγειρε
ξανά στη
Μόσχα το
άγαλμα του
ιδρυτή της KGB
Φέλιξ
Τζερζίνσκι.
Κάτι θα
ξέρει αυτός
για να το
κάνει.
#Post#: 20180--------------------------------------------------
Re: Η κηδεία το`
5; Στρατηγού Μ
προυσίλοφ
By: Αρχιφα
σίστας Dat
e: January 7, 2016, 9:38 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Long Knives 88 link=topic=2223.msg20179#msg20179
date=1452180929]
Πουτινικός
είμαι. Και αν
δεν υπήρχε
το 1919 ο
αταμάνος
Γκριγκόριε`
6;,
δε θα
υπήρχαν πια
Ρώσοι στην
Κριμαία, και
δε θα
μπορούσε
σήμερα η
Ρωσία να
υπερασπιστ^
9;ί
τα ιστορικά
εδάφη της.
Ο
Βλαδίμηρος
παρεμπιπτό_
7;τως
ανήγειρε
ξανά στη
Μόσχα το
άγαλμα του
ιδρυτή της KGB
Φέλιξ
Τζερζίνσκι.
Κάτι θα
ξέρει αυτός
για να το
κάνει.
[/quote]
??? ??? ???
Παράγοντας
του
Εδεσαικού
φάση...
#Post#: 20181--------------------------------------------------
Re: Η κηδεία το`
5; Στρατηγού Μ
προυσίλοφ
By: Long Knives 88 Date: January 7, 2016, 9:55 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Pepe the Frog link=topic=2223.msg20180#msg20180
date=1452181132]
??? ??? ???
Παράγοντας
του
Εδεσαικού
φάση...
[/quote]
Παράγοντας
του
Εδεσσαϊκού
είναι η φάση
για όποιον
δεν έχει
μελετήσει
σωστά την
ιστορία των
χρόνων 1917-23, και
νομίζει ότι
οι
Μπολσεβίκο_
3;
εξάπλωναν
δήθεν τον
κομμουνισμa
2;.
Στην
πραγματικό`
4;ητα
εξάπλωναν
τον
μεγαλορωσι_
4;ό
εθνικισμό.
Αν οι
μπολσεβίκο_
3;
τότε δεν
έπαιρναν
πίσω όλη την
αρχαία
ρώσικη γη,
σήμερα η
Ρωσία θα
ήταν ένα
μικρό
κράτος
γύρω-γύρω
από τη Μόσχα.
Δεν είναι
χαζός ο
Βλαδίμηρος
που λέει
συνέχεια
ότι το 1917-23
είναι ο
λόγος που
υπάρχει
σύγχρονο
μεγάλο
ρώσικο
κράτος στην
Ανατολική
Ευρώπη
σήμερα.
*****************************************************
DIR Next Page