DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       Walking Dead Fans
  HTML https://walkingdeadfans.createaforum.com
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       *****************************************************
   DIR Return to: General Discussion
       *****************************************************
       #Post#: 1286--------------------------------------------------
       Comic Andrea VS TV series Andrea
       By: Ickray_Imesgray Date: January 12, 2017, 12:06 am
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       I actually feel that Andrea from the tv series was better than
       comic Andrea, and that's because I feel that the character was
       given more depth and became someone a lot of people could relate
       to.
       After losing her sister she fell into depression and thought
       about ending her life and even wanted to go through with it at
       the CDC but Dale talked her out of it. After that she was mad
       but also trying to find a way to live with her pain and adapt to
       the new world.
       And then after Hershel's farm fell and she ended up with
       Michonne who saved her life and spent many months with. I did
       like that aspect, I felt it was a better introduction for
       Michonne than the comic. Then we get to the season 3 storyline
       and while I wasn't crazy about the writing for Andrea, I do
       understand why she did what she did.
       She was obviously blinded by who the Gov really was because she
       had fallen for his charm, which is very realistic in that sense
       because it happens all the time with people, especially abuse
       victims. But when she did eventually see how fucked up the gov
       was, she tried to get back to her real family and never made it.
       I still hate that she was killed off and I would have liked to
       see what Gimple could have done with the character, even if some
       of Gimple's story arcs aren't that great. But I do love Rick and
       Michonne together <3 so that's a plus, but yeah TV series Andrea
       just felt more real compared to comic Andrea, whereas comic
       Andrea just comes across as a mary sue, no offense.
       *****************************************************