DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
Walking Dead Fans
HTML https://walkingdeadfans.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: Consumed
*****************************************************
#Post#: 1183--------------------------------------------------
Options
DIR By: Rapscallion
Date: October 22, 2016, 3:43 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Do you think Daryl and Carol should've acted more aggressively
against the Grady Memorial cops instead of scouting them for
intelligence?
Daryl could've ran their car off the road. The cops would've
been caught off guard, and if they were injured in the crash,
they would've told Daryl and Carol everything about Grady
Memorial in exchange for help.
Daryl also could've rammed their car when they stopped in
Atlanta. In this scenario, the cops likely wouldn't have been
injured, but they'd still be caught off guard.
One cop looked back at Daryl and Carol's car when the walker was
clawing at it, so if Daryl thought the cop spotted them or chose
to investigate, he might've rammed their car to regain the upper
hand.
#Post#: 1184--------------------------------------------------
Re: Options
DIR By: Ickray_Imesgray
Date: October 22, 2016, 4:12 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Rapscallion link ---
>
> Do you think Daryl and Carol should've acted more aggressively
against the Grady Memorial cops instead of scouting them for
intelligence?
>
> Daryl could've ran their car off the road. The cops would've
been caught off guard, and if they were injured in the crash,
they would've told Daryl and Carol everything about Grady
Memorial in exchange for help.
>
> Daryl also could've rammed their car when they stopped in
Atlanta. In this scenario, the cops likely wouldn't have been
injured, but they'd still be caught off guard.
>
> One cop looked back at Daryl and Carol's car when the walker
was clawing at it, so if Daryl thought the cop spotted them or
chose to investigate, he might've rammed their car to regain the
upper hand.
>
--- End Quote ---
Nah I think they handled it pretty well the way they did it
originally. I don't think more aggression was the answer, but
they should've waited when they spotted that cop car. If Carol
didn't run out like she did, she wouldn't have gotten hit in the
first place. But of course that was the master plan to get her
into the hospital so Rick and the others would have to do a
trade.
I liked this episode a lot, I just wished the whole hospital arc
had been handled differently. I didn't like that Carol had to
end up there too.
#Post#: 1189--------------------------------------------------
Re: Options
DIR By: Rapscallion
Date: October 22, 2016, 5:49 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Ickray_Imesgray link ---
>
> Nah I think they handled it pretty well the way they did it
originally. I don't think more aggression was the answer, but
they should've waited when they spotted that cop car. If Carol
didn't run out like she did, she wouldn't have gotten hit in the
first place. But of course that was the master plan to get her
into the hospital so Rick and the others would have to do a
trade.
>
> I liked this episode a lot, I just wished the whole hospital
arc had been handled differently. I didn't like that Carol had
to end up there too.
>
--- End Quote ---
I hear what you're saying about discretion being the better part
of valor. Daryl and Carol handled themselves well in Atlanta,
but Noah appeared and screwed everything up.
I just think if Daryl had been aggressive instead of cautious,
he and Carol could've turned things into their favor and
negotiated for Beth's release later.
Gimple's big on characters doing stupid things to move the story
forward.
I enjoyed this episode too. I hated that Carol was captured,
but the hospital's staff was able to treat her injuries; the
group wouldn't have been able to do that. I'd have loved it if
Daryl had snuck into Grady Memorial and rescued her.
*****************************************************
Page 1 of 1