URI:
   DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       Sober Thinking
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       *****************************************************
   DIR Return to: Hydrocarbon Industry Skullduggery
       *****************************************************
       #Post#: 799--------------------------------------------------
       Since 1907 👀, The 🦕 Methane Gas Industry's Known
       Gas Stoves Are Dangerous. 😠
   DIR By: AGelbert
       Date: January 24, 2023, 11:07 am
       ---------------------------------------------------------
  HTML http://renewablerevolution.createaforum.com/gallery/renewablerevolution/2/3-270521170028.png
       Make Nexus Hot News part of your morning: click [i]here
  HTML https://climatenexus.org/hot-news/
       to subscribe.[/i]
       January 23, 2022
  HTML https://renewablerevolution.createaforum.com/gallery/renewablerevolution/3-121217195108.png
       [center]Since 1907, The 🦕 Methane Gas Industry's Known
       Gas Stoves Are Dangerous[/center]
       In 2023, in response to a new study showing that over one in
       eight cases of childhood asthma can be attributed to gas stove
       use, the 🦕 methane gas 👿 industry attacked the
       study as
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-040622202527-13931485.png<br
       />"not substantiated by sound science," invoking a phrase
       popularized by the tobacco industry. The American Gas
       Association’s &#128520; statement implied that inquiries into
       the negative health effects of gas stoves are a new phenomenon,
       writing that "as concerns over emissions from gas ranges are
       raised and debated," the trade association would "continue to
       work with regulators and policymakers to help ensure they have
       sound data to work with."
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-110822211037-18321080.jpeg
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-050422133654.gif<br
       />This could not be further from the truth. In fact, the
       industry
       should support recently-proposed regulations requiring gas
       stoves to be sold with ventilation hoods because it itself has
       recognized the vital importance of ventilating gas stoves for
       over a hundred years.
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-090422150144.png<br
       />
       Concerns about the health effects of gas stoves have existed
       since the 1800s. As early as 1839, "the injurious effects of an
       excess of nitrogen and carbonic acid gas" from gas stoves were
       already "too well known to require comment," according to a text
       on heating and ventilating public buildings and apartments.
       Since at least the early 1900s, the methane gas industry has
       known about the dangers of exposure to gas stove emissions in
       unventilated rooms. In the Proceedings of the Natural Gas
       Association of America from 1909, on page 193, that
       association's President Mitchell said he believes "the
       association will go on record" that "no gas of any kind should
       go into a heating stove without a flue connection." The
       following day of the group's second annual meeting in 1907
       opened with just that question, and debate ensued, with one
       person offering that they "cannot be responsible for people's
       carelessness." Ultimately, the group concluded that "we condemn
       any appliance installed in such a manner as to permit the
       products of combustion to enter the room."
       However, these early concerns did not stop the methane gas
       industry from aggressively promoting its toxic product. On page
       249 of the Proceedings, the group discusses the need for
       "constant advertising" about "the merits of gas as fuel" to gin
       up customers, such as the baker who "must be taught that no heat
       is more easily regulated: that the even temperature necessary
       for baking may be obtained from natural gas heat."
       In 1928, a San Diego public health official cited the American
       Gas Association's "experimentation" on carbon monoxide
       poisoning, which found that "a good deal depends upon
       intelligent installation of the proper gas appliances." While
       proper installation is indeed important, the AGA’s work seemed
       to essentially deflect blame onto consumers of second-hand
       stoves, stoves "which have never been inspected or approved by
       the American Gas Association," and those that lack "proper
       ventilation."
       In the following decades, the science behind the health
       consequences of gas stoves has strengthened. In 1947, MIT
       research chemist Richard Berger
       &#128104;&#8205;&#128300;&#128077; wrote in "To Prevent Cancer
  HTML https://www.industrydocuments.ucsf.edu/tobacco/docs/?utm_campaign=Hot%20News&utm_source=hs_email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=242784789&_hsenc=p2ANqtz--YQHtxdTvtua1YM99tFdoRJ5lKQSYn0zVuPTkONKAArmHUMwXiQ6B6e4lLlPcDsTGC0pLfuy0s4golbd1VyO8IHpwYbQ#id=jgmf0003"<br
       />that " the housewife who doesn’t smoke may make most of her
       carcinogenic contacts with coal tars from the kitchen stove
       (when coal or gas fired)" and that "Measured in terms of freedom
       from generation of carcinogenic irritants, electric heat
       (because it has no combustion products) is ideal for cooking and
       heating."
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-050422145344-560693.png
       [center]
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-240123125656.png[/center]
       (Side note: by 1958, the American Petroleum Institute's Smoke
       and Fumes' Committee on air pollution reported spending about a
       quarter-million dollars a year on research—about $2.5 million in
       today's dollars.)
       In 1977, researchers found "boys and girls from homes in which
       gas was used for cooking" had "more cough," chest colds and
       bronchitis, and "concluded that elevated levels of oxides from
       nitrogen arising from the combustion of gas might be the cause
       of the increased respiratory illness." A follow-up in 1979
       concurred: "The prevalence of one or more respiratory symptoms
       or diseases was higher in children from homes where gas was used
       for cooking than in those from homes where electricity was
       used."
       The twin asthmatic influence of tobacco smoking and gas cooking
       was noted as early as 1983: "exposure of children during the
       first two years of life to gas cooking or cigarette smoking
       appears to be associated with an increased risk of
       hospitalization for respiratory illness."
       Despite a century of "Cooking With Gas" advertisements,
       convincing people since 1909 that gas is great for baking and
       despite years of home renovation TV sponsorships, it looks like
       the&#129429; industry &#128520; conveniently forgot to let
       people know that it's dangerous not to ventilate your gas stove.
       
       The lack of public awareness about kitchen ventilation is
       evident in several more modern studies. In a 2007 survey, some
       39% of California households never, rarely, or only sometimes
       used their kitchen exhaust fans while using the stovetop. A 2014
       study found that while asthma rates were lower in children whose
       parents ventilated their gas stoves, over half of the families
       surveyed did not do so.
       Gas stoves are the only gas appliance that isn't required to
       have outdoor ventilation, and many people, particularly renters
       in low-income urban areas already facing a disproportionate
       impact from climate change and industrial pollution, simply do
       not have any ventilation for their stoves.
       The health consequences of gas stoves have been "raised and
       debated" since at least 1839, and the methane gas industry
       admitted to the need for proper ventilation of gas stoves as
       early as 1909. However, in 2023, over one hundred years later,
       the industry is choosing to completely reject even the most
       basic regulations of their toxic product, while Republicans are
       promising that you'll have to pry their gas stoves out of their
       cold, dead hands.
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-050422134013.gif
  HTML https://climatenexus.org/hot-news/
       #Post#: 963--------------------------------------------------
       &#129430; Koch network &#128013; operatives keep finding
       &#128520; success in running the same obvious disinfo &#128519;
       play. &#129318;&#8205;&#9794;&#65039;
   DIR By: AGelbert
       Date: March 25, 2023, 10:30 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
  HTML http://renewablerevolution.createaforum.com/gallery/renewablerevolution/2/3-270521170028.png
       Make Nexus Hot News part of your morning: click [i]here
  HTML https://climatenexus.org/hot-news/
       to subscribe.[/i]
       March 25, 2023
  HTML https://renewablerevolution.createaforum.com/gallery/renewablerevolution/3-121217195108.png
       [center][glow=maroon,2,300]&#128053; Dave &#128013;
       Wiegel[/glow] At Semafor Latest To Carry &#129430;
       [glow=red,2,300]Koch &#128519; Water[/glow] About Supposed
       Schism ::) With
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-080822134118-17091258.gif[size=24pt]&#129430;<br
       />[glow=red,2,300]Trump[/glow][/size][/center]
       It's 2015, and Koch network operatives are reportedly not
       working with Donald Trump's presidential campaign, as its
       operatives go to work for the Donald Trump campaign.
       It's 2016, and Koch network operatives are staffing Donald
       Trump's presidential transition team, and the Trump
       administration.
       It's 2017, and Koch network operative Mike Pence is Vice
       President under Donald Trump.
       It's 2018, and Koch network operatives are attacking the idea of
       more inclusive climate policy, and denying even their own
       anti-climate lobbying.
       It's 2019, and Koch network operatives are reframing themselves
       as climate champs, and rebranding as “Stand Together,” while
       lying about the Green New Deal and denying the climate
       consensus. "
       It's 2020, and a Koch network operative admits anyone who fell
       for the prior rebrand ruse is "going to be surprised" because
       the plan is "to go bigger than ever before." Ten months later, a
       Koch network operative, Charles “Chuckie” Koch gives an
       interview about the network's less-partisan rebrand, even as he
       sets up a new disinfo center at Tufts and spends over $1 billion
       helping Republicans in the 2020 elections.
       It's 2021, and Koch network operatives are lobbying against EPA
       regulations, using hundreds of millions of dollars in donations
       to inject disinfo into schools and universities.
       It's 2022, and Koch network operatives are telling media they're
       going to figure out who's behind all this polarization, as
       though they're not the ones spreading fake news attacking their
       clean competitors, defending doing business in Russia, spending
       over $50 million on climate disinfo, buying a Supreme Court
       majority, and sending errand-boy Mike Pence on an ill-fated
       anti-ESG crusade potentially robbing taxpayers of hundreds of
       millions to billions of dollars.
       It's 2023, and Koch network operatives are claiming to rebrand
       as less partisan and separate themselves from Donald Trump, not
       on ideological grounds, but because they want someone "who can
       win." Semafor, the newest entry in the access-driven DC press
       world, takes this as an opportunity to prove once again that it
       puts a greater priority in appeasing fossil fuel sponsors and
       billionaires who, like them, claim to want to reduce
       polarization, than it does on doing actual journalism.
       It's like Semafor's David Weigel read Popular Information's
       February explainer on "how Koch manipulates the media" and
       decided it was his turn to write the same exact sort of story
       that hacks have run about Koch and Trump since 2016, with a
       headline wondering, "Did Donald Trump break the Koch machine for
       good?"
       
       No.
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-070223165440.gif<br
       />
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-040622202629-14022441.gif
       For the past eight years, Koch network operatives have played
       supposedly-savvy DC reporters for saps, pretending to oppose a
       political operation even as they staff it.
       It's a testament to the perverse incentives of some Beltway
       press that—despite the obvious duplicity of these constant
       supposed rebrands—Koch network operatives keep finding success
       in running the same obvious disinfo play, even at outlets that,
       just days earlier, covered that playbook!
       Full Newsletter:
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-040422164555-532108.png
  HTML https://newsletter.climatenexus.org/20230324-are-you-sure-youre-in-good-hands?
       #Post#: 1310--------------------------------------------------
       The film, &quot;Killers of the Flower Moon,&quot; tells the
       story of the killing of Osage for their oil.  
   DIR By: AGelbert
       Date: September 14, 2023, 2:18 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       [center]
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-140923162545.jpeg[/center]
       September 14, 2023 by Greg Palast
       [center]"They couldn’t kill us all"[/center]
       [center]100 Crucial Seconds of A Story Buried[/center]
       
       The Osage of Oklahoma were the richest people on the planet.
       Until &#129429;&#129430; [glow=red,2,300]they[/glow] killed
       them.
       For their oil.
       This is an investigation I’ve worked on quietly for 27 years.
       And now I’m finally able to give you a 100-second preview, here…
       [center]Long Knife Teaser Original[/center]
       [center]
  HTML https://youtu.be/inoqKRlvav4[/center]
       In the 1920s, after discovery of the massive oil field on the
       Osage Reservation, the US government took away the Osage’s right
       to their wealth, instead appointing a
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-040622202719-1406786.gif<br
       />[glow=maroon,2,300]white Guardian[/glow] for each Osage to
       “protect” their money.
       Here’s how their [glow=red,2,300]guardians[/glow] protected
       them: Osage Anna Brown was shot in the head, her mother Lizzie
       poisoned, and her sister Rita was burnt to death when her home
       was dynamited.
       [center]
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-140923153712.jpeg[/center]
       Sixty, and likely many more, Osage were assassinated.  And their
       “
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-040622202719-1406786.gif<br
       />[glow=red,2,300]guardians[/glow],” their
       [glow=red,2,300]murderers[/glow] — inherited their oil rights.
       That story, of the murder-for-oil Reign of Terror, is movingly
       portrayed in the film, Killers of the Flower Moon, starring
       Leonardo DiCaprio, to be released next month.
       However, as Osage Principal Chief Geoffrey Standing Bear tells
       me, “But it’s not over. It’s still
       [glow=red,2,300]happening[/glow].”
  HTML http://media.tumblr.com/c6492e4b47cfdbd50e74d285fde3c53e/tumblr_inline_mm3g4yCaZc1qz4rgp.gif<br
       />
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-080422121109.gif
       Where Killers of the Flower Moon ends, our new documentary, Long
       Knife, begins: the hidden story of the Osage over the 100 years
       since the Reign of Terror.
       I’ve been waiting a long time to tell this story. Nearly three
       decades ago, as an expert in energy industry fraud and
       racketeering, I was asked to investigate the massive theft of
       oil from the Osage. The trail of evidence led straight to a guy
       I had never heard of, “Charlie” — Charles Koch.
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-140923151547-25311373.jpeg<br
       />I wrote a documentary exposing
       “[glow=red,2,300]
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-040622202719-14071062.gif<br
       />Charlie[/glow]” — but it never saw the light of day: no one
       cared about some small-time oil-rustler from Wichita.
       Now the story can at last be told: the &#9760;&#65039;
       [glow=red,2,300]genesis[/glow] of the
       &#129429;&#129430;[glow=red,2,300] Koch brothers’
       [/glow]&#128176; billions — and the creation of the Kochs’
       political
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-120422122619-6812456.gif&#9760;&#65039;<br
       />Death Star. The
       [glow=red,2,300]
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-040622210450-1415528.gif<br
       />Koch dark money machine[/glow] was first launched for the
       purpose of &#128520; quashing the federal indictment over his
       crimes against the Osage that promised to put
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-040622202719-1406786.gif[glow=red,2,300]<br
       />
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-010922192452.gifCharles<br
       />Koch[/glow] behind bars for a decade.
       We need your support to complete our film about the Kochs and
       the Osage’s unending fight for control of their own lands and
       lives.
       Join me...
       Add your name in the credits as a Producer, Co-Producer or
       Supporter.
       Or simply be a Film Backer.
       The “guardianship” horror was ended by Congress—but replaced by
       putting the Osage under “Trusteeship"
       Chief Standing Bear explains what he wants you to know:
       “…This is like a &#129421; military occupation. It is. This is
       our land, and we bought this land, this mineral estate, with our
       own money. Department of Interior, says, ‘It belongs to us and,
       and not you.’ And who do they get to help manage? Well, take a
       look: [glow=red,2,300]Koch Oil[/glow]. The end game is to
       extract as much wealth from our lands as possible.”
       Standing Bear, an accomplished trial attorney, showed me his
       name listed in the Bureau of Indian Affairs’ big leather book of
       “incompetent” Osage.
       It was not long ago that “incompetent” Osage literally couldn’t
       buy a sack of potatoes without approval of the BIA agent, the
       “Ma-he-kah,” the “Long Knife.”
       We have located some extraordinary people who have waited years
       to tell this story: The lead FBI agent who had an armed showdown
       with Koch operatives. And the US Prosecutor in charge of the
       Koch investigation for the US Senate—two men furious that Koch
       could bury a federal indictment. (We have a copy of it!) And we
       have filmed the confession of one of the men “Charlie” ordered
       to steal from the Osage—wounded to his soul for what he had to
       do to keep his job.
       And you’ll meet the Osage, warriors of a new kind. They have
       been left with 10,000 abandoned oil wells dripping poisons and
       spewing methane, possibly America’s worst source of ozone
       threatening discharges. Their fight has just begun.
       [center]
  HTML https://soberthinking.createaforum.com/gallery/soberthinking/1-140923151550-25412424.jpeg
       [/center]
       We need your help
  HTML https://palastinvestigativefund.org/longknife/,
       your commitment,
       your name in the credits, so these revelations can see the light
       of day.
       
       [center]LONG KNIFE[/center]
       [center]OSAGE OIL AND THE NEW TRAIL OF TEARS[/center]
       Reported by Greg Palast
       Directed by David Ambrose.
       And produced by George DiCaprio…and YOU
       *****************************************************
       Page 2 of 2
   DIR Previous Page