DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
RateTheRef
HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: General Discussion
*****************************************************
#Post#: 102645--------------------------------------------------
Galatasaray v Liverpool - Jesus Gil Manzano
By: Joecphillips Date: March 10, 2026, 2:44 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Interesting disallowed goal in this game, according to TNT UEFA
stated the goal was disallowed because it hit konate’s arm and
went straight in however replays show that vvd actually played
the ball after this
#Post#: 102647--------------------------------------------------
Re: Galatasaray v Liverpool - Jesus Gil Manzano
By: Adam Date: March 10, 2026, 2:51 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
The following is under the umbrella of Liverpool didnt deserve
anything from this game and that the result very much reflected
both teams' performances.
That has to be one of the worst performances in a long time from
Gil Mazano.
Firstly, Galas 2nd goal shouldn't have been disallowed. A
generational mess up at the back which the offside player had
absolutely no impact. Terrible from VAR.
Then Liverpool categorically shouldn't have had their goal
disallowed. The official reasoning from VAR was that it went
into the goal straight off Konates arm, which is factually
incorrect. It deflects off about 3 other players before ending
in.the goal. And even if it came off Konates hand again before
going in the goal, there is absolutely no angles that show that,
so how the goal was disallowed is a mystery.
All of the above coupled with random foul detection, player
reactions being used to judge on yellow cards as well as some
dreadful free kick signalling in the box made it an extremely
poor performance for Mazano. Given the talent in the UEFA pool,
he shouldn't been seen again in this competition this season.
On a side note, Spanish refereeing really isn't in a good way.
Sanchez Martinez is bang average, with his sending to the World
Cup being a token political gesture as performances really
haven't warranted it. I do like Hernandez, the new Elite
referee, so i really hope he can continue his good form, as the
2 above him really are not good enough to be Spains leading
referees.
#Post#: 102659--------------------------------------------------
Re: Galatasaray v Liverpool - Jesus Gil Manzano
By: TC021002 Date: March 10, 2026, 4:20 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Alberola Rojas who was recently promoted to Cat 1 looks a good
future Spanish elite list official. I agree that Hernandez is
probably the better of the 3 currently on the elite list but it
seems that Sanchez will go to the world cup (although his
mistake in Atalanta/Dortmund wouldn't have helped him)
#Post#: 102661--------------------------------------------------
Re: Galatasaray v Liverpool - Jesus Gil Manzano
By: El Referee Date: March 10, 2026, 4:28 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Adam link=topic=7802.msg102647#msg102647
date=1773172286]
The following is under the umbrella of Liverpool didnt deserve
anything from this game and that the result very much reflected
both teams' performances.
That has to be one of the worst performances in a long time from
Gil Mazano.
Firstly, Galas 2nd goal shouldn't have been disallowed. A
generational mess up at the back which the offside player had
absolutely no impact. Terrible from VAR.
Then Liverpool categorically shouldn't have had their goal
disallowed. The official reasoning from VAR was that it went
into the goal straight off Konates arm, which is factually
incorrect. It deflects off about 3 other players before ending
in.the goal. And even if it came off Konates hand again before
going in the goal, there is absolutely no angles that show that,
so how the goal was disallowed is a mystery.
All of the above coupled with random foul detection, player
reactions being used to judge on yellow cards as well as some
dreadful free kick signalling in the box made it an extremely
poor performance for Mazano. Given the talent in the UEFA pool,
he shouldn't been seen again in this competition this season.
On a side note, Spanish refereeing really isn't in a good way.
Sanchez Martinez is bang average, with his sending to the World
Cup being a token political gesture as performances really
haven't warranted it. I do like Hernandez, the new Elite
referee, so i really hope he can continue his good form, as the
2 above him really are not good enough to be Spains leading
referees.
[/quote]
Wasn’t the greatest performance by the officials or Liverpool,
but wasn’t the goal disallowed for handball by Van Dijk, not
Konate?
#Post#: 102669--------------------------------------------------
Re: Galatasaray v Liverpool - Jesus Gil Manzano
By: Adam Date: March 10, 2026, 5:20 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=El Referee link=topic=7801.msg102661#msg102661
date=1773178085]
[quote author=Adam link=topic=7802.msg102647#msg102647
date=1773172286]
The following is under the umbrella of Liverpool didnt deserve
anything from this game and that the result very much reflected
both teams' performances.
That has to be one of the worst performances in a long time from
Gil Mazano.
Firstly, Galas 2nd goal shouldn't have been disallowed. A
generational mess up at the back which the offside player had
absolutely no impact. Terrible from VAR.
Then Liverpool categorically shouldn't have had their goal
disallowed. The official reasoning from VAR was that it went
into the goal straight off Konates arm, which is factually
incorrect. It deflects off about 3 other players before ending
in.the goal. And even if it came off Konates hand again before
going in the goal, there is absolutely no angles that show that,
so how the goal was disallowed is a mystery.
All of the above coupled with random foul detection, player
reactions being used to judge on yellow cards as well as some
dreadful free kick signalling in the box made it an extremely
poor performance for Mazano. Given the talent in the UEFA pool,
he shouldn't been seen again in this competition this season.
On a side note, Spanish refereeing really isn't in a good way.
Sanchez Martinez is bang average, with his sending to the World
Cup being a token political gesture as performances really
haven't warranted it. I do like Hernandez, the new Elite
referee, so i really hope he can continue his good form, as the
2 above him really are not good enough to be Spains leading
referees.
[/quote]
Wasn’t the greatest performance by the officials or Liverpool,
but wasn’t the goal disallowed for handball by Van Dijk, not
Konate?
[/quote]
Apparently not. Thats what I assumed and what would make more
sense (even though it actually doesn't touch his arm),
commentators on 2 different feeds i had access to (TNT and I
think the world feed) both said that they had been told it was
for Konate, which is just wrong.
#Post#: 102671--------------------------------------------------
Re: Galatasaray v Liverpool - Jesus Gil Manzano
By: Scally Bob Date: March 10, 2026, 6:14 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
I’ve just arrived back at our hotel from Galatasaray. We
couldn’t see what happened as it was at the far end of the
ground but the screen showed a message that the goal was
disallowed because Liverpool number 5 (Konate) had scored with
his hand.
We were awful tonight and Galatasaray were barely any better but
the third team were the worst on display. Foul detection was
totally inconsistent, Osimhen and the Galatasaray number 53
should both have been cautioned for persistent infringement and
the referee was naive in the extreme falling for time-wasting.
#Post#: 102675--------------------------------------------------
Re: Galatasaray v Liverpool - Jesus Gil Manzano
By: bmb Date: March 11, 2026, 5:25 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Dale Johnson says
HTML https://x.com/DaleJohnsonBBC/status/2031459336329806089?s=20
Ok, so the VAR is saying that the ball hit Konate's arm twice.
Firstly from the corner delivery, and then after the ball came
off Van Dijk's heel.
If that is the case, it would make it Konate's goal, and correct
to rule out Liverpool's goal without an on-field review.
#Post#: 102682--------------------------------------------------
Re: Galatasaray v Liverpool - Jesus Gil Manzano
By: ajb95 Date: March 11, 2026, 11:12 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=TC021002 link=topic=7801.msg102659#msg102659
date=1773177619]
Alberola Rojas who was recently promoted to Cat 1 looks a good
future Spanish elite list official. I agree that Hernandez is
probably the better of the 3 currently on the elite list but it
seems that Sanchez will go to the world cup (although his
mistake in Atalanta/Dortmund wouldn't have helped him)
[/quote]
Montero as well is pretty decent
#Post#: 102684--------------------------------------------------
Re: Galatasaray v Liverpool - Jesus Gil Manzano
By: TC021002 Date: March 11, 2026, 12:54 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=ajb95 link=topic=7801.msg102682#msg102682
date=1773245558]
[quote author=TC021002 link=topic=7801.msg102659#msg102659
date=1773177619]
Alberola Rojas who was recently promoted to Cat 1 looks a good
future Spanish elite list official. I agree that Hernandez is
probably the better of the 3 currently on the elite list but it
seems that Sanchez will go to the world cup (although his
mistake in Atalanta/Dortmund wouldn't have helped him)
[/quote]
Montero as well is pretty decent
[/quote]
Yeah he's maybe been unlucky not to have gotten many UEFA games
but he won't get promoted due to age.
*****************************************************