DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
RateTheRef
HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: Non Footy Appointments
*****************************************************
#Post#: 9098--------------------------------------------------
Re: ICC Cricket World Cup 2019
DIR By: Acme Thunderer
Date: July 6, 2019, 4:45 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Mackem ref link ---
>
> Congratulations to Ian Gould who will stand in his final
international match as an umpire today. Arguably the most
well-respected official by players in modern times!
>
--- End Quote ---
Agreed, but does that mean that there is no chance of seeing Ian
in a Semi or even the Final? Accepting the need for neutrality,
I would still hope that umpires from the nations competing in
the semi-finals will not be precluded from umpiring at this
stage of the competition. Let's hope the rain we've been having
in the NW this morning doesn't spoil Ian's big day at Leeds.
#Post#: 9099--------------------------------------------------
Re: ICC Cricket World Cup 2019
DIR By: Mackem ref
Date: July 6, 2019, 5:35 am
---------------------------------------------------------
It’s been reported in the media as his final game (including bbc
live text). Maybe Ian asked not to be considered for a knockout
game, meaning he knew well in advance where his career would
finish to get family/friends there to support him??
#Post#: 9110--------------------------------------------------
Re: ICC Cricket World Cup 2019
DIR By: tomp
Date: July 7, 2019, 4:43 am
---------------------------------------------------------
9th July
Semi-Final:
India Vs New Zealand
Old Trafford
Umpires: Richard Illingworth and Richard Kettleborough
Third Umpire: Rod Tucker
Reserve Umpire: Nigel Llong
Match Referee: David Boon
11th July
Semi-Final:
Australia Vs England
Edgbaston
Umpires: Kumar Dharmasena and Marais Erasmus
Third Umpire: Chris Gaffaney
Reserve Umpire: Aleem Dar
Match Referee: Ranjan Madugalle
#Post#: 9111--------------------------------------------------
Re: ICC Cricket World Cup 2019
DIR By: 2ndcity95
Date: July 7, 2019, 5:13 am
---------------------------------------------------------
No real surprises for the England v Australia semi final. I have
to say I'm shocked that Richard Illingworth has been appointed
to the other semi final, don't thinks he's ever really been near
a world tournament semi-final before if I remember correctly and
I've never considered him in the top bracket of ICC umpires. I
personally thought that Rod Tucker was nailed on for an
old-field spot in that semi-final.
#Post#: 9123--------------------------------------------------
Re: ICC Cricket World Cup 2019
DIR By: greeny
Date: July 8, 2019, 12:36 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Here are the stats on reviews for the group stage for each
umpire:
Aleem Dar:
Decisions reviewed: 7
Upheld: 5
Reversed: 1
Umpire's Call: 1
Kumar Dharmasena
Decisions reviewed: 9
Upheld: 7
Reversed: 2
Marais Erasmus
Decisions reviewed: 2
Upheld: 2
Chris Gaffaney
Decisions reviewed: 8
Upheld: 2
Reversed: 4
Umpire's Call: 2
Ian Gould
Decisions reviewed: 4
Upheld: 1
Reversed: 3
Richard Illingworth
Decisions reviewed: 5
Upheld: 2
Reversed: 2
Umpire's Call: 1
Richard Kettleborough
Decisions reviewed: 7
Upheld: 1
Reversed: 4
Umpire's Call: 2
Nigel Llong
Decisions reviewed: 3
Upheld: 1
Reversed: 1
Umpire's Call: 1
Bruce Oxenford
Decisions reviewed: 5
Upheld: 3
Reversed: 2
Sundaram Ravi
Decisions reviewed: 4
Upheld: 3
Reversed: 1
Paul Reiffel
Decisions reviewed: 3
Upheld: 2
Reversed: 1
Rod Tucker
Decisions reviewed: 2
Upheld: 2
Michael Gough
Decisions reviewed: 6
Upheld: 4
Umpire's Call: 2
Ruchira Palliyaguruge
Decisions reviewed: 9
Upheld: 3
Reversed: 4
Umpire's Call: 2
Joel Wilson
Decisions reviewed: 5
Upheld: 2
Reversed: 1
Umpire's Call: 2
Paul Wilson
Decisions reviewed: 10
Upheld: 3
Reversed: 4
Umpire's Call: 3
These stats only reflect decisions that were reviewed - from
what I saw, there were a number of calls that should have been
reviewed but weren't - either because the team chose not to
review, or couldn't (because they'd used their review already).
#Post#: 9134--------------------------------------------------
Re: ICC Cricket World Cup 2019
DIR By: Hendo
Date: July 8, 2019, 5:01 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: tomp link ---
>
> 9th July
>
> Semi-Final:
>
> India Vs New Zealand
> Old Trafford
> Umpires: Richard Illingworth and Richard Kettleborough
> Third Umpire: Rod Tucker
> Reserve Umpire: Nigel Llong
> Match Referee: David Boon
>
> 11th July
>
> Semi-Final:
>
>
> Australia Vs England
> Edgbaston
> Umpires: Kumar Dharmasena and Marais Erasmus
> Third Umpire: Chris Gaffaney
> Reserve Umpire: Aleem Dar
> Match Referee: Ranjan Madugalle
>
--- End Quote ---
Wonder how much these are on merit or just “political”?
To me both Dharmasena and Kettleborough have been less than
impressive at this World Cup and Gaffeney not much better.
#Post#: 9142--------------------------------------------------
Re: ICC Cricket World Cup 2019
DIR By: BabyRef
Date: July 9, 2019, 6:25 am
---------------------------------------------------------
I suppose an England-Australia semi rules out most of the
officials - they need to pick four from seven!
#Post#: 9162--------------------------------------------------
Re: ICC Cricket World Cup 2019
DIR By: Hendo
Date: July 11, 2019, 11:15 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Hendo link ---
>
> [quote author=tomp link=topic=745.msg9110#msg9110
date=1562492590]
> 9th July
>
> Semi-Final:
>
> India Vs New Zealand
> Old Trafford
> Umpires: Richard Illingworth and Richard Kettleborough
> Third Umpire: Rod Tucker
> Reserve Umpire: Nigel Llong
> Match Referee: David Boon
>
> 11th July
>
> Semi-Final:
>
>
> Australia Vs England
> Edgbaston
> Umpires: Kumar Dharmasena and Marais Erasmus
> Third Umpire: Chris Gaffaney
> Reserve Umpire: Aleem Dar
> Match Referee: Ranjan Madugalle
>
--- End Quote ---
Wonder how much these are on merit or just “political”?
To me both Dharmasena and Kettleborough have been less than
impressive at this World Cup and Gaffeney not much better.
[/quote]
That none sense over Roy’s “dismissal” is another indication of
what a poor WC Dharmasena has had.
I predict now that Erasmus and Tucker will get the final, with
Reiffel as 3rd umpire
#Post#: 9163--------------------------------------------------
Re: ICC Cricket World Cup 2019
DIR By: Mackem ref
Date: July 11, 2019, 1:35 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Based on how the ICC have appointed in the past, I would bet on
Erasmus and Dharmasena to stand in the final, despite the
latter’s indifferent performance!
#Post#: 9164--------------------------------------------------
Re: ICC Cricket World Cup 2019
DIR By: reflector
Date: July 11, 2019, 2:23 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Hendo link ---
>
> [quote author=Hendo link=topic=745.msg9134#msg9134
date=1562623303]
> [quote author=tomp link=topic=745.msg9110#msg9110
date=1562492590]
> 9th July
>
> Semi-Final:
>
> India Vs New Zealand
> Old Trafford
> Umpires: Richard Illingworth and Richard Kettleborough
> Third Umpire: Rod Tucker
> Reserve Umpire: Nigel Llong
> Match Referee: David Boon
>
> 11th July
>
> Semi-Final:
>
>
> Australia Vs England
> Edgbaston
> Umpires: Kumar Dharmasena and Marais Erasmus
> Third Umpire: Chris Gaffaney
> Reserve Umpire: Aleem Dar
> Match Referee: Ranjan Madugalle
>
--- End Quote ---
Wonder how much these are on merit or just “political”?
To me both Dharmasena and Kettleborough have been less than
impressive at this World Cup and Gaffeney not much better.
[/quote]
That none sense over Roy’s “dismissal” is another indication of
what a poor WC Dharmasena has had.
I predict now that Erasmus and Tucker will get the final, with
Reiffel as 3rd umpire
[/quote]
I think that's a pretty good shout for the Final. Actually,
until today I thought that I had seen an improvement in
Dharmasena in this world cup but the Roy decision was awful,
particularly for someone who has now stood in over 100 one day
internationals. The pity is that he, as the villain of the
piece will get away with it and Roy will get penalised for his
dissent, despite the tremendous provocation. Yes, I know that
players should accept the decisions of officials but sometimes
when they are so bad, particularly in matches of this
importance, that even Mother Teresa would have probably been
minded to whisper an expletive.
*****************************************************
Page 6 of 8
DIR Previous Page
DIR Next Page