DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
RateTheRef
HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: Select Group - Premier League
*****************************************************
#Post#: 92020--------------------------------------------------
Re: Fri 16th – Tue 20th MAY 2025
By: bmb Date: May 14, 2025, 7:24 am
---------------------------------------------------------
It was not the best feedback after the Bournemouth game, not
sure on the Luton one. I'm sure he has grown and developed since
then & it may well have just been one of those days at the
office for him. I'm not going to judge a referee after having
watched them only once, first impressions were not good though.
#Post#: 92072--------------------------------------------------
Re: Fri 16th – Tue 20th MAY 2025
By: Matt1234 Date: May 15, 2025, 6:22 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Scott Ledger has replaced Richard West as AR2 on Chelsea v
Manchester United
#Post#: 92075--------------------------------------------------
Re: Fri 16th – Tue 20th MAY 2025
By: referee12 Date: May 15, 2025, 6:56 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Hopefully kitchen and Webb will get more prem run outs next
season
#Post#: 92079--------------------------------------------------
Re: Fri 16th – Tue 20th MAY 2025
By: Adam Date: May 15, 2025, 10:03 am
---------------------------------------------------------
If they were sensible they'd promote 2 to cover the void left by
Scott and Tierney and then perhaps one more just to give
strength in numbers.
I'd say Kitchen and L.Smith if they go for 2 or Webb included if
they go for 3.
With assistants they need at least 2 to replace Cann and
Lennard, and with West being injured more than he is fit I'd
promote a 3rd to again give strength in numbers.
#Post#: 92081--------------------------------------------------
Re: Fri 16th – Tue 20th MAY 2025
By: TA_Ref Date: May 15, 2025, 10:34 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Adam link=topic=6997.msg92079#msg92079
date=1747321406]
If they were sensible they'd promote 2 to cover the void left by
Scott and Tierney and then perhaps one more just to give
strength in numbers.
I'd say Kitchen and L.Smith if they go for 2 or Webb included if
they go for 3.
With assistants they need at least 2 to replace Cann and
Lennard, and with West being injured more than he is fit I'd
promote a 3rd to again give strength in numbers.
[/quote]
I would still like to see Josh Smith promoted to SG1 but once
again he seems to have picked up an injury again and has been
out of the picture for quite a while now.
Personally, I’d say Webb and Kitchen should be promoted purely
because they’ve been very consistent performers in the
championship for this season. In my opinion, their promotions
would be deserved on merit.
This is not me being against Lewis Smith at all but I don’t
think he’s had a long consistent run of games in the
championship/prem for him to deserve SG1 status. Don’t get me
wrong I’ve seen him have excellent performances this year
(Ipswich v Fulham springs to mind) but some of his appointments
have been a bit all over the shop this year (no blame attached
to him at all). I just think Webb and Kitchen have been more
consistent than Lewis Smith in a higher division. I still
believe Lewis Smith will get there as he is developing as a
referee very well but maybe just a season too soon for him in my
eyes.
#Post#: 92090--------------------------------------------------
Re: Fri 16th – Tue 20th MAY 2025
By: bmb Date: May 15, 2025, 11:33 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Adam link=topic=6997.msg92079#msg92079
date=1747321406]
If they were sensible
[/quote]
Loving the optimism of some sense being used!
#Post#: 92091--------------------------------------------------
Re: Fri 16th – Tue 20th MAY 2025
By: rustyref Date: May 15, 2025, 12:02 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=TA_Ref link=topic=6997.msg92081#msg92081
date=1747323288]
[quote author=Adam link=topic=6997.msg92079#msg92079
date=1747321406]
If they were sensible they'd promote 2 to cover the void left by
Scott and Tierney and then perhaps one more just to give
strength in numbers.
I'd say Kitchen and L.Smith if they go for 2 or Webb included if
they go for 3.
With assistants they need at least 2 to replace Cann and
Lennard, and with West being injured more than he is fit I'd
promote a 3rd to again give strength in numbers.
[/quote]
I would still like to see Josh Smith promoted to SG1 but once
again he seems to have picked up an injury again and has been
out of the picture for quite a while now.
Personally, I’d say Webb and Kitchen should be promoted purely
because they’ve been very consistent performers in the
championship for this season. In my opinion, their promotions
would be deserved on merit.
This is not me being against Lewis Smith at all but I don’t
think he’s had a long consistent run of games in the
championship/prem for him to deserve SG1 status. Don’t get me
wrong I’ve seen him have excellent performances this year
(Ipswich v Fulham springs to mind) but some of his appointments
have been a bit all over the shop this year (no blame attached
to him at all). I just think Webb and Kitchen have been more
consistent than Lewis Smith in a higher division. I still
believe Lewis Smith will get there as he is developing as a
referee very well but maybe just a season too soon for him in my
eyes.
[/quote]
If Google is correct, David Webb will be 50 by the start of the
next season, I'd be extremely surprised if he is promoted to SG1
at that age.
#Post#: 92129--------------------------------------------------
Re: Fri 16th – Tue 20th MAY 2025
By: PhiltheRef Date: May 16, 2025, 2:16 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Excuse my ignorance.
Why can't MO do those games please?
#Post#: 92135--------------------------------------------------
Re: Fri 16th – Tue 20th MAY 2025
By: Claretman Date: May 16, 2025, 7:33 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=PhiltheRef link=topic=6997.msg92129#msg92129
date=1747422986]
Excuse my ignorance.
Why can't MO do those games please?
[/quote]
Being a Newcastle supporter he would recuse himself from any
game in which could influence the champions league
qualification.
If Newcastle were to beat Arsenal in this set of fixtures and
thus qualify for the champions league due to superior goal
difference over Villa then he may get appointed to the Man Utd v
Villa game or the Nottm Forest v Chelsea game i would suppose.
#Post#: 92211--------------------------------------------------
Re: Fri 16th – Tue 20th MAY 2025
By: Mackem ref Date: May 18, 2025, 3:26 am
---------------------------------------------------------
I see Brooks replaced by Madley on Monday night - a return of
his injury perhaps? Hope it doesn’t ruin his chances of
attending the Euro 21s this summer
*****************************************************
DIR Previous Page
DIR Next Page