DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
RateTheRef
HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: General Discussion
*****************************************************
#Post#: 91481--------------------------------------------------
Re: E ESKAS - Bilbao v Man U
DIR By: PhiltheRef
Date: May 1, 2025, 3:24 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
What has Lindelof got to do with it please?
#Post#: 91482--------------------------------------------------
Re: E ESKAS - Bilbao v Man U
DIR By: Rhys147
Date: May 1, 2025, 3:25 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Pm2 link ---
>
> [quote author=Rhys147 link=topic=6959.msg91479#msg91479
date=1746130846]
> I think that Man Utd are very lucky that wasn't a free kick
against them as it was very similar to the penalty that was
given and if we are talking about consistency then it should be
a free kick and a red card against Lindelof.
>
--- End Quote ---
if you can’t see a clear difference there then it’s a big
problem.ther was no hold by maguire
[/quote]
Well thankfully for you, I'm not a Referee and I will never be
one but as this site says everyone is allowed an opinion as long
as they don't abuse other users on this site which I haven't or
abuse the ref which I also haven't. I've explained why I don't
think it's a penalty and I don't think you need to be saying
there is a big problem because I am entitled to my opinion.
#Post#: 91483--------------------------------------------------
Re: E ESKAS - Bilbao v Man U
DIR By: Rhys147
Date: May 1, 2025, 3:26 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: PhiltheRef link ---
>
> What has Lindelof got to do with it please?
>
--- End Quote ---
Sorry I thought it was Lindelof but it was Maguire.
#Post#: 91484--------------------------------------------------
Re: E ESKAS - Bilbao v Man U
DIR By: Pm2
Date: May 1, 2025, 3:28 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Rhys147 link ---
>
> [quote author=Pm2 link=topic=6959.msg91480#msg91480
date=1746130923]
> [quote author=Rhys147 link=topic=6959.msg91479#msg91479
date=1746130846]
> I think that Man Utd are very lucky that wasn't a free kick
against them as it was very similar to the penalty that was
given and if we are talking about consistency then it should be
a free kick and a red card against Lindelof.
>
--- End Quote ---
if you can’t see a clear difference there then it’s a big
problem.ther was no hold by maguire
[/quote]
Well thankfully for you, I'm not a Referee and I will never be
one but as this site says everyone is allowed an opinion as long
as they don't abuse other users on this site which I haven't or
abuse the ref which I also haven't. I've explained why I don't
think it's a penalty and I don't think you need to be saying
there is a big problem because I am entitled to my opinion.
[/quote] well apologies my fault for saying it’s a problem but
imo never a foul
#Post#: 91485--------------------------------------------------
Re: E ESKAS - Bilbao v Man U
DIR By: Rhys147
Date: May 1, 2025, 3:30 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Pm2 link ---
>
> [quote author=Rhys147 link=topic=6959.msg91482#msg91482
date=1746131106]
> [quote author=Pm2 link=topic=6959.msg91480#msg91480
date=1746130923]
> [quote author=Rhys147 link=topic=6959.msg91479#msg91479
date=1746130846]
> I think that Man Utd are very lucky that wasn't a free kick
against them as it was very similar to the penalty that was
given and if we are talking about consistency then it should be
a free kick and a red card against Lindelof.
>
--- End Quote ---
if you can’t see a clear difference there then it’s a big
problem.ther was no hold by maguire
[/quote]
Well thankfully for you, I'm not a Referee and I will never be
one but as this site says everyone is allowed an opinion as long
as they don't abuse other users on this site which I haven't or
abuse the ref which I also haven't. I've explained why I don't
think it's a penalty and I don't think you need to be saying
there is a big problem because I am entitled to my opinion.
[/quote] well apologies my fault for saying it’s a problem but
imo never a foul
[/quote]
And I respect your opinion as you are entitled to it just as I
am entitled to mine. I am more than happy for you to educate me
on why it's a penalty and why it's not a foul but as with a lot
of things in football, there is subjectivity to it so one person
will see something one way and someone else will see it the
other.
#Post#: 91486--------------------------------------------------
Re: E ESKAS - Bilbao v Man U
DIR By: dave26
Date: May 1, 2025, 3:40 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Rhys147 link ---
>
> [quote author=Pm2 link=topic=6959.msg91484#msg91484
date=1746131283]
> [quote author=Rhys147 link=topic=6959.msg91482#msg91482
date=1746131106]
> [quote author=Pm2 link=topic=6959.msg91480#msg91480
date=1746130923]
> [quote author=Rhys147 link=topic=6959.msg91479#msg91479
date=1746130846]
> I think that Man Utd are very lucky that wasn't a free kick
against them as it was very similar to the penalty that was
given and if we are talking about consistency then it should be
a free kick and a red card against Lindelof.
>
--- End Quote ---
if you can’t see a clear difference there then it’s a big
problem.ther was no hold by maguire
[/quote]
Well thankfully for you, I'm not a Referee and I will never be
one but as this site says everyone is allowed an opinion as long
as they don't abuse other users on this site which I haven't or
abuse the ref which I also haven't. I've explained why I don't
think it's a penalty and I don't think you need to be saying
there is a big problem because I am entitled to my opinion.
[/quote] well apologies my fault for saying it’s a problem but
imo never a foul
[/quote]
And I respect your opinion as you are entitled to it just as I
am entitled to mine. I am more than happy for you to educate me
on why it's a penalty and why it's not a foul but as with a lot
of things in football, there is subjectivity to it so one person
will see something one way and someone else will see it the
other.
[/quote]
I ageee with your last paragraph but in UEFA competitions I just
cannot see a referee not giving it however in the PL I think the
referees would be split on it
#Post#: 91487--------------------------------------------------
Re: E ESKAS - Bilbao v Man U
DIR By: Charlieboy
Date: May 1, 2025, 3:43 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Rhys147 link ---
>
> [quote author=Pm2 link=topic=6959.msg91484#msg91484
date=1746131283]
> [quote author=Rhys147 link=topic=6959.msg91482#msg91482
date=1746131106]
> [quote author=Pm2 link=topic=6959.msg91480#msg91480
date=1746130923]
> [quote author=Rhys147 link=topic=6959.msg91479#msg91479
date=1746130846]
> I think that Man Utd are very lucky that wasn't a free kick
against them as it was very similar to the penalty that was
given and if we are talking about consistency then it should be
a free kick and a red card against Lindelof.
>
--- End Quote ---
if you can’t see a clear difference there then it’s a big
problem.ther was no hold by maguire
[/quote]
Well thankfully for you, I'm not a Referee and I will never be
one but as this site says everyone is allowed an opinion as long
as they don't abuse other users on this site which I haven't or
abuse the ref which I also haven't. I've explained why I don't
think it's a penalty and I don't think you need to be saying
there is a big problem because I am entitled to my opinion.
[/quote] well apologies my fault for saying it’s a problem but
imo never a foul
[/quote]
And I respect your opinion as you are entitled to it just as I
am entitled to mine. I am more than happy for you to educate me
on why it's a penalty and why it's not a foul but as with a lot
of things in football, there is subjectivity to it so one person
will see something one way and someone else will see it the
other.
[/quote]
Pm2 apologised accept it and move on please.
#Post#: 91489--------------------------------------------------
Re: E ESKAS - Bilbao v Man U
DIR By: PhiltheRef
Date: May 1, 2025, 3:49 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Perhaps, with respect, everyone might park it now and move on?
*****************************************************
Page 2 of 2
DIR Previous Page