DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
RateTheRef
HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: Select Group - Premier League
*****************************************************
#Post#: 86162--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 21st DEC 2024 – Wed 1st JAN 2025
By: TheThingFromLewes Date: December 17, 2024, 10:12 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Mr Castilli link=topic=6530.msg86161#msg86161
date=1734451419]
Barrott for Spurs v Lpool after last seasons farce ??
Too big for him again imo! Should have been Taylor or Oliver
only or Gillett.
Good spread around, would have been good to of seen Josh Smith
with a run out but nope nothing.
Also has Allison not lived up to the hype ? As Webb has not used
him since September.
[/quote]
I have to disagree strongly with that analogy that it is too big
a game for him.
He handled Arsenal v Man U very well, and apart from a minor
blip a month or so ago, has probably performed better than
anyone in the SG. You don’t get appointed to big games if there
is a whim of scepticism from the PGMOL.
Add to this, that the fiasco last season was nothing to do with
the referee, VAR was the sole culprit of the unfortunate offside
decision. That is probably why Oliver is fourth official and
they have put Tierney in VAR, who has shown this season to be
very logical and methodical in the VAR booth.
#Post#: 86163--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 21st DEC 2024 – Wed 1st JAN 2025
By: TVOS Date: December 17, 2024, 10:26 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Mr Castilli link=topic=6530.msg86161#msg86161
date=1734451419]
Barrott for Spurs v Lpool after last seasons farce ??
Too big for him again imo! Should have been Taylor or Oliver
only or Gillett.
Good spread around, would have been good to of seen Josh Smith
with a run out but nope nothing.
Also has Allison not lived up to the hype ? As Webb has not used
him since September.
[/quote]
Gillett the Liverpool fan?
#Post#: 86164--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 21st DEC 2024 – Wed 1st JAN 2025
By: Pm2 Date: December 17, 2024, 10:32 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Some great appointments there.bankes has had a good season and
deserves city villa.barrott with a big game that’s going to be
feisty after last year…
Brilliant to see gillett back with 2 championship games
#Post#: 86165--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 21st DEC 2024 – Wed 1st JAN 2025
By: TA_Ref Date: December 17, 2024, 10:35 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Another amazing appointment for Sam Barrott - great for him.
Certainly our next UEFA referee and it seems our next two after
Oliver and Taylor will be Barrott and Brooks.
Trying to pick out the big games from this list…
Peter Bankes with a good game at Villa Park. Both teams not as
good as they were last season but still a very good appointment
for him
Taylor with a big basement battle on Sunday with Leicester v
Wolves - potential to get a bit nasty that one so a safe pair of
hands with the most in form official in my opinion.
No particular ‘big games’ across Boxing Day and the 27th.
Bramall, Bond and Lewis Smith with games in this gameweek which
is good for them.
Oliver has Man City again for which I believe is the 5th (!?)
time which is far too excessive in my opinion. To have one
referee 5 times before New Year is ludicrous. I can accept 5
times over the whole season but definitely not 5 in this period
of time.
Hooper as well at Old Trafford with a decent game too.
For my team, we have Attwell, England and Brooks which I’m happy
about. (The last time we went to North London we had Darren
England as ref and that went quite well. Hopefully a repeat
😅).
#Post#: 86167--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 21st DEC 2024 – Wed 1st JAN 2025
By: Matt1234 Date: December 17, 2024, 10:56 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Here is a break down of the appointments for all Full Time SG1
referees and Assistant Referees:
Referees-
Attwell- 1 x Ref PL, 0 X FO, 2 x VAR, 1 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
Bankes- 2 x Ref PL, 0 X FO, 1 x VAR, 1 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
Barrott- 2 x Ref PL, 1 x FO, 0 x VAR, 1 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
Bond- 1 x Ref PL, 3 x FO, 0 x VAR, 1 x Ref Champ (5 apps in
total)
Brammall- 1 x Ref PL, 2 x FO, 0 x VAR, 1 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
Brooks- 1 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 3 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
England- 1 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 3 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
Gillett- 0 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 3 x VAR, 2 x Ref Champ (5 apps in
total)
Harrington- 2 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 0 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (2 apps
in total)
Hooper- 3 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 0 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (3 apps in
total)
Jones- 2 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 0 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (2 apps in
total)
Kavanagh- 2 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 2 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
Madley- 1 x Ref PL, 2 x FO, 0 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (3 apps in
total)
Oliver- 2 x Ref PL, 1 x FO, 1 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
Pawson- 3 x Ref PL, 1 x FO, 0 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
Robinson- 1 x Ref PL, 1 x FO, 0 x VAR, 1 x Ref Champ (3 apps in
total)
Salisbury- 1 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 3 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
Scott- 0 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 4 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (4 apps in
total)
Taylor- 3 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 0 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (3 apps in
total)
Tierney- 0 x Ref PL, 0 x FO, 5 x VAR, 0 x Ref Champ (5 apps in
total)
Assistants
Aspinall- 1 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Bennett- 3 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Beswick- 2 x Assist PL, 0 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Betts- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Burt- 3 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
Total)
Cann- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Cook- 0 x Assist PL, 3 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Davies- 3 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Eaton- 1 x Assist PL, 0 x AVAR, 2 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Greenhalgh- 3 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Hatzidakis- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Holmes- 3 x Assist PL, 0 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Hopton- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Howson- 2 x Assist PL, 2 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Hussin- 3 x Assist PL, 0 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Ledger- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Long- 3 x Assist PL, 0 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Mainwaring- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Massey-Ellis- 0 x Assist PL, 2 x AVAR, 2 x Assist Champ (4 apps
in total)
Meredith- 1 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Nunn- 3 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Perry- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Robathan- 3 x Assist PL, 0 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Scholes- 0 x Assist PL, 3 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Smart- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 1x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Smith- 2 x Assist PL, 0 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
C Taylor- 1 x Assist PL, 2 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
West- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 0 x Assist Champ (3 apps in
total)
Wilkes- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
Wood- 2 x Assist PL, 1 x AVAR, 1 x Assist Champ (4 apps in
total)
L Smith- 1 x Ref PL, 1 x FO PL, 1 x Champ Ref, 2 x League 1 Ref
(5 apps in total)
Chilowicz- 2 x VAR, 1 x Ref League 1, 1 x Ref League 2 (4 apps
in total)
Donohue- 1 x VAR, 2 x Champ Ref (3 apps in total)
#Post#: 86168--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 21st DEC 2024 – Wed 1st JAN 2025
By: ajb95 Date: December 17, 2024, 11:30 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=TA_Ref link=topic=6530.msg86165#msg86165
date=1734453331]
Another amazing appointment for Sam Barrott - great for him.
Certainly our next UEFA referee and it seems our next two after
Oliver and Taylor will be Barrott and Brooks.
Trying to pick out the big games from this list…
Peter Bankes with a good game at Villa Park. Both teams not as
good as they were last season but still a very good appointment
for him
Taylor with a big basement battle on Sunday with Leicester v
Wolves - potential to get a bit nasty that one so a safe pair of
hands with the most in form official in my opinion.
No particular ‘big games’ across Boxing Day and the 27th.
Bramall, Bond and Lewis Smith with games in this gameweek which
is good for them.
Oliver has Man City again for which I believe is the 5th (!?)
time which is far too excessive in my opinion. To have one
referee 5 times before New Year is ludicrous. I can accept 5
times over the whole season but definitely not 5 in this period
of time.
Hooper as well at Old Trafford with a decent game too.
For my team, we have Attwell, England and Brooks which I’m happy
about. (The last time we went to North London we had Darren
England as ref and that went quite well. Hopefully a repeat
😅).
[/quote]
Yep fifth time. And a lot of refs haven’t had them once yet
#Post#: 86169--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 21st DEC 2024 – Wed 1st JAN 2025
By: Hertsref123 Date: December 17, 2024, 11:40 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Mr Castilli link=topic=6530.msg86161#msg86161
date=1734451419]
Barrott for Spurs v Lpool after last seasons farce ??
Too big for him again imo! Should have been Taylor or Oliver
only or Gillett.
Good spread around, would have been good to of seen Josh Smith
with a run out but nope nothing.
Also has Allison not lived up to the hype ? As Webb has not used
him since September.
[/quote]
He's already had Arsenal V Man United (Which you also complained
about him getting), Do we really Wanna go back to the old days
under Hackett where only a small handfull of refs did the "top 6
clashes"?
If we don't start giving other refs those clashes when will they
ever learn? Oliver and Taylor won't be around forever.
#Post#: 86176--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 21st DEC 2024 – Wed 1st JAN 2025
By: rustyref Date: December 17, 2024, 2:04 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=TVOS link=topic=6530.msg86163#msg86163
date=1734452805]
[quote author=Mr Castilli link=topic=6530.msg86161#msg86161
date=1734451419]
Barrott for Spurs v Lpool after last seasons farce ??
Too big for him again imo! Should have been Taylor or Oliver
only or Gillett.
Good spread around, would have been good to of seen Josh Smith
with a run out but nope nothing.
Also has Allison not lived up to the hype ? As Webb has not used
him since September.
[/quote]
Gillett the Liverpool fan?
[/quote]
And he's coming back from injury, with just Championship middles
given to him. Would obviously make absolute sense to give the
biggest game of the weekend to a referee that hasn't blown a
whistle in anger for 3 months 🤷‍♂️
#Post#: 86182--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 21st DEC 2024 – Wed 1st JAN 2025
By: Pm2 Date: December 17, 2024, 4:34 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Was the last time that Oliver was 4O also Liverpool spurs last
season?
#Post#: 86183--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 21st DEC 2024 – Wed 1st JAN 2025
By: DerbyLad90 Date: December 17, 2024, 4:58 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Premier League royalty at Pride Park Boxing Day on his return
from injury
*****************************************************
DIR Previous Page
DIR Next Page