DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       RateTheRef
  HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       *****************************************************
   DIR Return to: Euros 2024
       *****************************************************
       #Post#: 80790--------------------------------------------------
       Re: Istvan Kovacs: Turkey v Czech Republic 
       By: ARF Date: June 30, 2024, 3:05 am
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       [quote author=Leggy link=topic=6092.msg80763#msg80763
       date=1719685073]
       [quote author=ARF link=topic=6092.msg80745#msg80745
       date=1719603440]
       [quote author=Leggy link=topic=6092.msg80726#msg80726
       date=1719574138]
       But a holding offence (even a bog standard one) is likely to
       attract a caution simply because it cannot be explained away as
       a mistimed challenge for the ball.  It is an intentional act to
       impede an opponent.  Holding is never accidental.
       [/quote]
       Being intentional doesn't make it a cautionable offence.
       [quote author=Arbitre anglais link=topic=6092.msg80736#msg80736
       date=1719591121]
       Get where you’re coming from, and would be an easy YC to
       ‘manage’ (ie ignore) as the first one. Not sure it’s quite just
       holding whilst challenging - if a player turns you / gets away
       from you, and you clearly pull them back by the shirt, it’s
       almost always a YC. It certainly has been in this tournament
       and, if players go on to get YCs (even 2YCs) later in the game
       for the same offence, it always seems unfair if a another player
       got a free one because it happens to be early.
       [/quote]
       Off-hand I can't say I remember a player being cautioned for an
       offence like this - I vaguely recall a few where they were
       cautioned as it was stopping a promising attack though. I'm sure
       I've seen other players this tournament penalised for
       holding/pulling offences without being cautioned.
       [/quote]
       Not explicitly, but intentionally holding an opponent is as good
       an example of unsporting behaviour as one can find.  You cannot
       use hands to tackle / challenge so doing so is an intentional
       and pre-determined act.
       [/quote]
       As you stated, holding is never accidental, so by that logic any
       and all holding offences are cautions? Behave!
       *****************************************************
   DIR Previous Page
   DIR Next Page