DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
RateTheRef
HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: General Discussion
*****************************************************
#Post#: 75204--------------------------------------------------
Re: Bournemouth v Forest - Rebecca Welch
DIR By: Seagull
Date: February 4, 2024, 10:33 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: bmb link ---
>
> [quote author=Seagull link=topic=5666.msg75200#msg75200
date=1707063851]
> [quote author=thesensibleone link=topic=5666.msg75194#msg75194
date=1707062521]
> It’s a mixed bag of foul detection, agreed that kluivert
should have gone, but booked omobamidele for waving an imaginary
yellow in same incident. So Rebecca is probably thinking I’m not
sending him off because you tell me too. But in any case he
should have gone. But made a good call for the Billing sending
off described as a hack down the achilles. I think her fitness
is ok and I rate her but I just think today her foul detection
and issuing misconduct let her down a bit today.
>
--- End Quote ---
Or maybe she simply didn't think it was a cautionable offence? I
say that not having seen it yet for myself.
[/quote]
It was very cautionable! Trust me - he's a lucky boy he stayed
on the pitch long enough to be subbed!!
[/quote]
Fair enough. I may well draw the same conclusion when I see it
later on TV, bmb.
#Post#: 75215--------------------------------------------------
Re: Bournemouth v Forest - Rebecca Welch
DIR By: Hertsref123
Date: February 4, 2024, 11:32 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Mr Castilli link ---
>
> Oh Welsh !! Very Poor… Kluivert has to go, people on Twitter
up in arms, clear 2nd yellow missed and kluivert substituted
straight away.
>
> Sadly Welsh has been pushed through this fast track system far
too quickly ! Has barely bedded in at Championship level !
>
> Edited to correct spelling of refs name in title! bmb
>
--- End Quote ---
You seem very quick to come on here, and scream that a ref isn’t
good enough, based on one decision. I do hope your not an
observer with all due respect, As I don’t think any ref you’d
observe would get anywhere.
#Post#: 75217--------------------------------------------------
Re: Bournemouth v Forest - Rebecca Welch
DIR By: ajb95
Date: February 4, 2024, 11:39 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Cant comment on her overall performance but an excellent
decision for the red card. Challenges like that are seldom
punished with a red so glad to see this one was and correctly
so!
#Post#: 75218--------------------------------------------------
Re: Bournemouth v Forest - Rebecca Welch
DIR By: Smithy
Date: February 4, 2024, 11:50 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Interesting reading the opinions here. I don’t have one as I
didn’t see it so maybe she was poor maybe she wasn’t.
But if I may reiterate a previously made point which seems
relevant again today as the conversation about her performance
takes place, her performance is of secondary importance.
Number one remains that the English Premier League has a female
referee. If she was good then that’s great, if she wasn’t…ah
well!!!
#Post#: 75220--------------------------------------------------
Re: Bournemouth v Forest - Rebecca Welch
DIR By: guest308
Date: February 4, 2024, 11:57 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Smithy link ---
>
> Interesting reading the opinions here. I don’t have one as I
didn’t see it so maybe she was poor maybe she wasn’t.
> But if I may reiterate a previously made point which seems
relevant again today as the conversation about her performance
takes place, her performance is of secondary importance.
> Number one remains that the English Premier League has a
female referee. If she was good then that’s great, if she
wasn’t…ah well!!!
>
--- End Quote ---
I wish you wouldn’t reiterate it ! You have made that point ,we
all know your opinion it does not need repeating . The only
conclusion I can come to is you are doing so for a reaction ? As
repetitive posting serves no other purpose .
#Post#: 75231--------------------------------------------------
Re: Bournemouth v Forest - Rebecca Welch
DIR By: TheThingFromLewes
Date: February 4, 2024, 12:45 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Smithy link ---
>
> Interesting reading the opinions here. I don’t have one as I
didn’t see it so maybe she was poor maybe she wasn’t.
> But if I may reiterate a previously made point which seems
relevant again today as the conversation about her performance
takes place, her performance is of secondary importance.
> Number one remains that the English Premier League has a
female referee. If she was good then that’s great, if she
wasn’t…ah well!!!
>
--- End Quote ---
Can we please draw a line on this continual posting on this
matter. As I said earlier, it’s getting boring and you’ve said
what you want to say.
Please let’s move on with constructive posts rather than this
material.
#Post#: 75239--------------------------------------------------
Re: Bournemouth v Forest - Rebecca Welch
DIR By: Smithy
Date: February 4, 2024, 1:04 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: charlieboy link ---
>
> [quote author=Smithy link=topic=5666.msg75218#msg75218
date=1707069047]
> Interesting reading the opinions here. I don’t have one as I
didn’t see it so maybe she was poor maybe she wasn’t.
> But if I may reiterate a previously made point which seems
relevant again today as the conversation about her performance
takes place, her performance is of secondary importance.
> Number one remains that the English Premier League has a
female referee. If she was good then that’s great, if she
wasn’t…ah well!!!
>
--- End Quote ---
I wish you wouldn’t reiterate it ! You have made that point ,we
all know your opinion it does not need repeating . The only
conclusion I can come to is you are doing so for a reaction ? As
repetitive posting serves no other purpose .
[/quote]
It is a relevant topic relevant to the thread. An earlier poster
stated the opinion that Welsh is an excellent referee who is
where she is on merit. That opinion has also been stated before
without attack. Please can we have some consistency here??
#Post#: 75241--------------------------------------------------
Re: Bournemouth v Forest - Rebecca Welch
DIR By: Smithy
Date: February 4, 2024, 1:09 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: TheThingFromLewes link ---
>
> [quote author=Smithy link=topic=5666.msg75218#msg75218
date=1707069047]
> Interesting reading the opinions here. I don’t have one as I
didn’t see it so maybe she was poor maybe she wasn’t.
> But if I may reiterate a previously made point which seems
relevant again today as the conversation about her performance
takes place, her performance is of secondary importance.
> Number one remains that the English Premier League has a
female referee. If she was good then that’s great, if she
wasn’t…ah well!!!
>
--- End Quote ---
Can we please draw a line on this continual posting on this
matter. As I said earlier, it’s getting boring and you’ve said
what you want to say.
Please let’s move on with constructive posts rather than this
material.
[/quote]
Will you please refrain from posting about Trevor Kettle and his
son in other areas of the forum? Given what you have said to me
I think that’s fair to ask.
#Post#: 75246--------------------------------------------------
Re: Bournemouth v Forest - Rebecca Welch
DIR By: Adam
Date: February 4, 2024, 1:20 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Smithy link ---
>
> [quote author=TheThingFromLewes
link=topic=5666.msg75231#msg75231 date=1707072303]
> [quote author=Smithy link=topic=5666.msg75218#msg75218
date=1707069047]
> Interesting reading the opinions here. I don’t have one as I
didn’t see it so maybe she was poor maybe she wasn’t.
> But if I may reiterate a previously made point which seems
relevant again today as the conversation about her performance
takes place, her performance is of secondary importance.
> Number one remains that the English Premier League has a
female referee. If she was good then that’s great, if she
wasn’t…ah well!!!
>
--- End Quote ---
Can we please draw a line on this continual posting on this
matter. As I said earlier, it’s getting boring and you’ve said
what you want to say.
Please let’s move on with constructive posts rather than this
material.
[/quote]
Will you please refrain from posting about Trevor Kettle and his
son in other areas of the forum? Given what you have said to me
I think that’s fair to ask.
[/quote]
Even though I am not a long time user of this site, even I know
that the Kettle saga is a long running joke here and I for one
would love to discuss him every now and again. If you don't like
it go take yourself elsewhere. I feel that was a very dangerous
remark to make and I forsee some of the veterans on this site
will be rightly annoyed by thus.
With regards to Welch, she has proved herself time after time on
the women's stage at the highest level that she is the country's
best of her gender alongside Cheryl Foster. She had been great
in League One and the Championship and in the midst of an injury
crisis she was given a warranted opportunity in the Prem which
she performed well in, hence why she got the game today. She
didn't perform, it'll be a while before she gets another game,
move on. Your remarks towards her and Allison are becoming
borderline sexist and racist. You have an agenda against them.
#Post#: 75248--------------------------------------------------
Re: Bournemouth v Forest - Rebecca Welch
DIR By: ajb95
Date: February 4, 2024, 1:23 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Adam link ---
>
> [quote author=Smithy link=topic=5666.msg75241#msg75241
date=1707073765]
> [quote author=TheThingFromLewes
link=topic=5666.msg75231#msg75231 date=1707072303]
> [quote author=Smithy link=topic=5666.msg75218#msg75218
date=1707069047]
> Interesting reading the opinions here. I don’t have one as I
didn’t see it so maybe she was poor maybe she wasn’t.
> But if I may reiterate a previously made point which seems
relevant again today as the conversation about her performance
takes place, her performance is of secondary importance.
> Number one remains that the English Premier League has a
female referee. If she was good then that’s great, if she
wasn’t…ah well!!!
>
--- End Quote ---
Can we please draw a line on this continual posting on this
matter. As I said earlier, it’s getting boring and you’ve said
what you want to say.
Please let’s move on with constructive posts rather than this
material.
[/quote]
Will you please refrain from posting about Trevor Kettle and his
son in other areas of the forum? Given what you have said to me
I think that’s fair to ask.
[/quote]
Even though I am not a long time user of this site, even I know
that the Kettle saga is a long running joke here and I for one
would love to discuss him every now and again. If you don't like
it go take yourself elsewhere. I feel that was a very dangerous
remark to make and I forsee some of the veterans on this site
will be rightly annoyed by thus.
With regards to Welch, she has proved herself time after time on
the women's stage at the highest level that she is the country's
best of her gender alongside Cheryl Foster. She had been great
in League One and the Championship and in the midst of an injury
crisis she was given a warranted opportunity in the Prem which
she performed well in, hence why she got the game today. She
didn't perform, it'll be a while before she gets another game,
move on. Your remarks towards her and Allison are becoming
borderline sexist and racist. You have an agenda against them.
[/quote]
With respect, the women’s game is nowhere near the standard, or
scrutiny of the PL. and also you can’t really judge someone on a
dozen EFL games of which none of been “hard” or important games
like derbies
*****************************************************
Page 2 of 4
DIR Previous Page
DIR Next Page