DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
RateTheRef
HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: Select Group - Premier League
*****************************************************
#Post#: 64223--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 20th – Thu 25th MAY 2023
By: Claretman Date: May 16, 2023, 4:27 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=TVOS link=topic=4916.msg64213#msg64213
date=1684268457]
[quote author=Hendo link=topic=4916.msg64195#msg64195
date=1684257981]
[quote author=RCG link=topic=4916.msg64191#msg64191
date=1684255178]
All Bramhall needs to do is look at Simon Hooper - knuckle down,
work hard, take chances when they come
[/quote]
Or change his name to Robert Madley. As I have said a few times
the writing has been on the wall most of the season and Webb and
co. couldn’t wait to get him back in the SG.
I am sure some on here will rejoice but not me.
[/quote]
Must be all that Yorkshire bias, tha knows...
Dickie Bird will be joining SG1 next!!
[/quote]
At 90 Bird probably fits the age criteria😂
#Post#: 64225--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 20th – Thu 25th MAY 2023
By: Whistleblower Date: May 16, 2023, 4:57 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
I think Robinson and R Madley will be promoted to SG1 and if
they take a third it will be Smith I suspect. It appears that
Bond has perhaps had an injury at an unfortunate time as he also
seemed to be very much in the frame and perhaps he still is.
I do not like R Madley's style of officiating, he always seems
very keen on making it about himself, but I suspect he is a very
competent technical referee and this accounts for his
promotions. I guess he is now too old to regain a FIFA Badge but
here's a prediction. In two or three years time he will be
getting more top fixtures than his brother and I am sure, in
time, the fates ( or the Yorkshire Fairy Godmother ) have
decreed that they will both receive an FA Cup Final.
#Post#: 64227--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 20th – Thu 25th MAY 2023
By: rustyref Date: May 16, 2023, 5:02 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Whistleblower link=topic=4916.msg64225#msg64225
date=1684274271]
I think Robinson and R Madley will be promoted to SG1 and if
they take a third it will be Smith I suspect. It appears that
Bond has perhaps had an injury at an unfortunate time as he also
seemed to be very much in the frame and perhaps he still is.
I do not like R Madley's style of officiating, he always seems
very keen on making it about himself, but I suspect he is a very
competent technical referee and this accounts for his
promotions. I guess he is now too old to regain a FIFA Badge but
here's a prediction. In two or three years time he will be
getting more top fixtures than his brother and I am sure, in
time, the fates ( or the Yorkshire Fairy Godmother ) have
decreed that they will both receive an FA Cup Final.
[/quote]
Not sure if there is still an age limit for getting onto FIFA,
but when there was it only applied to the initial joining. If
you "left" you could then come back after you were older than
that age. So as Bobby Madley was on before any age limit
wouldn't apply to him.
#Post#: 64231--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 20th – Thu 25th MAY 2023
By: jacksamuel21 Date: May 16, 2023, 5:33 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
I might be in the minority and think Bobby Madley isn’t actually
that bad, he is better than Bankes, Coote, Harrington and
Salisbury for me.
Not sure I agree on him getting another chance so quickly though
#Post#: 64234--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 20th – Thu 25th MAY 2023
By: jacksamuel21 Date: May 16, 2023, 5:51 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Readingfan link=topic=4916.msg64177#msg64177
date=1684233538]
[quote author=Mackem ref link=topic=4916.msg64173#msg64173
date=1684229736]
What must Brammall be thinking given how few games he has had
and yet again overlooked for an SG2 referee…..
[/quote]
Good game for Marriner. I'm a bit surprised at Bankes doing such
a big game at this stage of the season. There's been a lot of
talk about Oliver and if him not doing Newcastle games would
affect other appointments but I think it was suggested Coote
didn't referee Nottingham Forest but he's got the Everton game.
[/quote]
I know it becomes difficult but I agree in the Bankes point
Peter Bankes- on a match with directly affects Everton
Michael Oliver- 40 on a Liverpool match
David Coote- directly affects Nottingham Forest
Rob Jones- Newcastle match? Affects Liverpool
Michael Salisbury- VAR on a Man United game- affects Liverpool
Also, Ian Hussin (Liverpool fan) on A Man United match and Dan
Cook (doesn’t officiate Manchester sides) on Newcastle
Poor appointing with just two weeks to go. Yes they are
professional and it won’t affect the match officials but Last
thing you want is a referee making a hugely controversial
decision, which happens to directly benefit the team they
support.
#Post#: 64235--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 20th – Thu 25th MAY 2023
By: RCG Date: May 16, 2023, 10:30 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
It is about opinion and I too am not a fan of his style.
However, he did not leave PL list (or FIFA) due to ability or
performance, so once he had worked through his period of
pennance, one assumes his ability has not suddenly vanished and
therefore he we would be returned to SG1. It will be interesting
to see the shake up once the season is finally over.
#Post#: 64242--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 20th – Thu 25th MAY 2023
By: takethejag Date: May 17, 2023, 4:10 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Hughesy66 link=topic=4916.msg64189#msg64189
date=1684253223]
Robert Madley seems to heavily divide opinion on here which is
of course the name of this site so that’s fine. However, to call
him a rookie ref is some distance from the truth.
I believe Mr Madley has refereed around 100 EPL matches and
spent 4 or 5 years on the SG1 referee list.
To refer to someone of that experience a rookie is either not
knowing your referees or simply ignorant to even check.
An interesting set of fixtures. As has been stated I do wonder
what Mr Bramall makes of his lack of appointments this season
[/quote]
I'd say the opinion on Bobby Madley is fairly in agreement, most
of us of here don't rate him but I'm happy to be proved
wrong/listen to other opinions. To clarify my point, I've edited
my post, the term 'rookie' was in general about how Fulham
always seem to the test-bed for SG2 promotion potential, of
which these are usually rookie (at PL level). Obviously in this
case Madley isn't a rookie in that respect, so let's hope he's
able to start to prove me wrong on Saturday!
#Post#: 64247--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 20th – Thu 25th MAY 2023
By: jacksamuel21 Date: May 17, 2023, 6:38 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Why is Peter Bankes at West Ham? He did their last home game,
where he missed a stonewall handball, just two weeks ago.
Ridiculous.
#Post#: 64253--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 20th – Thu 25th MAY 2023
By: Whistleblower Date: May 17, 2023, 7:43 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=rustyref link=topic=4916.msg64227#msg64227
date=1684274567]
[quote author=Whistleblower link=topic=4916.msg64225#msg64225
date=1684274271]
I think Robinson and R Madley will be promoted to SG1 and if
they take a third it will be Smith I suspect. It appears that
Bond has perhaps had an injury at an unfortunate time as he also
seemed to be very much in the frame and perhaps he still is.
I do not like R Madley's style of officiating, he always seems
very keen on making it about himself, but I suspect he is a very
competent technical referee and this accounts for his
promotions. I guess he is now too old to regain a FIFA Badge but
here's a prediction. In two or three years time he will be
getting more top fixtures than his brother and I am sure, in
time, the fates ( or the Yorkshire Fairy Godmother ) have
decreed that they will both receive an FA Cup Final.
[/quote]
Not sure if there is still an age limit for getting onto FIFA,
but when there was it only applied to the initial joining. If
you "left" you could then come back after you were older than
that age. So as Bobby Madley was on before any age limit
wouldn't apply to him.
[/quote]
Assuming R Madley does attain SG1 status it will be interesting
to see if anyone else is asked to 'surrender' their FIFA Badge
so he may receive one. In a plot worthy of a paperback Western,
maybe his brother will relinquish his Sheriff's Badge to him or
it may be that he will be appointed when Anthony Taylor steps
down from international duties.
#Post#: 64261--------------------------------------------------
Re: Sat 20th – Thu 25th MAY 2023
By: jacksamuel21 Date: May 17, 2023, 10:07 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Whistleblower link=topic=4916.msg64253#msg64253
date=1684327386]
[quote author=rustyref link=topic=4916.msg64227#msg64227
date=1684274567]
[quote author=Whistleblower link=topic=4916.msg64225#msg64225
date=1684274271]
I think Robinson and R Madley will be promoted to SG1 and if
they take a third it will be Smith I suspect. It appears that
Bond has perhaps had an injury at an unfortunate time as he also
seemed to be very much in the frame and perhaps he still is.
I do not like R Madley's style of officiating, he always seems
very keen on making it about himself, but I suspect he is a very
competent technical referee and this accounts for his
promotions. I guess he is now too old to regain a FIFA Badge but
here's a prediction. In two or three years time he will be
getting more top fixtures than his brother and I am sure, in
time, the fates ( or the Yorkshire Fairy Godmother ) have
decreed that they will both receive an FA Cup Final.
[/quote]
Not sure if there is still an age limit for getting onto FIFA,
but when there was it only applied to the initial joining. If
you "left" you could then come back after you were older than
that age. So as Bobby Madley was on before any age limit
wouldn't apply to him.
[/quote]
Assuming R Madley does attain SG1 status it will be interesting
to see if anyone else is asked to 'surrender' their FIFA Badge
so he may receive one. In a plot worthy of a paperback Western,
maybe his brother will relinquish his Sheriff's Badge to him or
it may be that he will be appointed when Anthony Taylor steps
down from international duties.
[/quote]
England is most likely to step down I would feel as I don't see
a future on the FIFA stage for him
*****************************************************
DIR Previous Page
DIR Next Page