DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       RateTheRef
  HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       *****************************************************
   DIR Return to: General Discussion
       *****************************************************
       #Post#: 3613--------------------------------------------------
       Re: Liv Ars Oliver; rangers v. Celtic Beaton
   DIR By: Vlad Vladadze
       Date: December 30, 2018, 2:24 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       Please find below the videos of most interesting incidents
       Morelos x2
  HTML https://streamable.com/s73jn
  HTML https://streamable.com/ik56v
       Brown's tackle
  HTML https://streamable.com/6vwak
       Handball in the box
  HTML https://streamable.com/31hqo
       #Post#: 3616--------------------------------------------------
       Re: Liv Ars Oliver; rangers v. Celtic Beaton
   DIR By: RCG
       Date: December 30, 2018, 3:12 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       I would be interested to know Vlad which of those you personally
       would have wanted action taking in.
       First petulant kick is a YC at worst
       The stamp/forceful tread is hard to spot in real time but yes,
       red card for me
       Tackle outside of penalty area his foot lifts after he has
       played the ball and as a result of his heel hitting the ground,
       to me a controlled sliding tackle
       And if thats handball then the law should just say if it hits
       hands give penalty
       #Post#: 3618--------------------------------------------------
       Re: Liv Ars Oliver; rangers v. Celtic Beaton
   DIR By: ajb95
       Date: December 30, 2018, 3:20 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       --- Quote from: Readingfan link ---
       >
       > I hadn't seen Beaton before but was very impressed. What is
       his background/age? Does he have any prospects on the
       international scene?
       >
       > I thought Oliver generally did well although I thought Arsenal
       should have had a penalty with the benefit of the replay.
       >
       --- End Quote ---
       I think he’s early to mid thirties similar to Kavanagh I think.
       He’s in category 1 for uefa and has some decent games.
       I think he will replace Collin in elite group - he’s the best
       ref in Scotland at the moment alongside Madden
       #Post#: 3620--------------------------------------------------
       Re: Liv Ars Oliver; rangers v. Celtic Beaton
   DIR By: Vlad Vladadze
       Date: December 30, 2018, 4:15 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       --- Quote from: RCG link ---
       >
       > I would be interested to know Vlad which of those you
       personally would have wanted action taking in.
       > First petulant kick is a YC at worst
       > The stamp/forceful tread is hard to spot in real time but yes,
       red card for me
       > Tackle outside of penalty area his foot lifts after he has
       played the ball and as a result of his heel hitting the ground,
       to me a controlled sliding tackle
       > And if thats handball then the law should just say if it hits
       hands give penalty
       >
       --- End Quote ---
       RC for both Morelos' actions, clear violent conducts, imho.
       RC for endangering the safety of an opponent to Brown - playing
       the ball at first is not the end of action nowadays and there
       was a big and high contact between Brown's studs and opponent's
       leg.
       The handball is debatable for me, but in UEFA the hand position
       would be deemed as unnatural (hand outstretched too much).
       #Post#: 3642--------------------------------------------------
       Re: Liv Ars Oliver; rangers v. Celtic Beaton
   DIR By: Steelman
       Date: December 31, 2018, 12:46 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       --- Quote from: ajb95 link ---
       >
       > [quote author=Readingfan link=topic=429.msg3594#msg3594
       date=1546186776]
       > I hadn't seen Beaton before but was very impressed. What is
       his background/age? Does he have any prospects on the
       international scene?
       >
       > I thought Oliver generally did well although I thought Arsenal
       should have had a penalty with the benefit of the replay.
       >
       --- End Quote ---
       I think he’s early to mid thirties similar to Kavanagh I think.
       He’s in category 1 for uefa and has some decent games.
       I think he will replace Collin in elite group - he’s the best
       ref in Scotland at the moment alongside Madden
       [/quote]
       John Beaton is 36 and hails from Motherwell, and indeed I
       believe he used to live very close to Fir Park. Steady official
       who usually puts in a decent performance, but I don't think he
       is as good as Bobby Madden, but could potentially go further as
       he is 4 years younger than Madden. Our best prospects long term
       are Don Robertson (31) and Nick Walsh (28), the latest to
       benefit from Scotland's long held tradition of putting guys on
       the FIFA list early to give them the best chance of progress.
       *****************************************************
       Page 2 of 2
   DIR Previous Page