DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
RateTheRef
HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: General Discussion
*****************************************************
#Post#: 47874--------------------------------------------------
Roma vs Leicester - Srjdan Jovanovic
DIR By: Referee99
Date: May 5, 2022, 4:14 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
I have to chose my words wisely as I don’t want to get banned
HOWEVER
that was THE worst performance by a team of officials (mainly
the referee) that I have ever witnessed.
How the hell did he get a semi final when he can’t even get the
simplest of decisions.
Don’t get me wrong, Leicester were poor and probably didn’t
deserve to win, however Mr Jovanovic was a disgrace tonight
#Post#: 47876--------------------------------------------------
Re: Roma vs Leicester - Srjdan Jovanovic
DIR By: RCG
Date: May 5, 2022, 4:19 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Examples of incorrect decisions? Was he consistent to both
sides? What could/should he have done differently?
#Post#: 47879--------------------------------------------------
Re: Roma vs Leicester - Srjdan Jovanovic
DIR By: DublinRef
Date: May 5, 2022, 4:30 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Referee99 link ---
>
> I have to chose my words wisely as I don’t want to get banned
HOWEVER
>
> that was THE worst performance by a team of officials (mainly
the referee) that I have ever witnessed.
>
> How the hell did he get a semi final when he can’t even get
the simplest of decisions.
>
> Don’t get me wrong, Leicester were poor and probably didn’t
deserve to win, however Mr Jovanovic was a disgrace tonight
>
--- End Quote ---
I didn't see it and maybe he had a bad game but I agree with the
point RCG makes. If we are going to label a referee as a
disgrace (not that I think we really should) then I think the
post should include some analysis or discussion of the incident.
Plus I would be genuinely interested to hear your thoughts on
where he went wrong.
#Post#: 47880--------------------------------------------------
Re: Roma vs Leicester - Srjdan Jovanovic
DIR By: guest308
Date: May 5, 2022, 4:32 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
I’ve learnt from experience it’s best not to write a post
immediately after the game when. You might still be angry or
aggrieved, always best to sleep on it think it through and try
to reason your statements.
#Post#: 47886--------------------------------------------------
Re: Roma vs Leicester - Srjdan Jovanovic
DIR By: Ref95
Date: May 5, 2022, 5:10 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Mr Jovanovic had an extremely poor game and looked well out of
his depth in all honesty, without there being any major decisons
in the game. The only decisions that could have been considered
anywhere near ‘big decisions’ were:
Penalty appeal for a foul on Fofana by Smalling after 3 minutes
for a holding offence from a corner. Appeared to be a clear
foul, but a subjective decision and I can support VAR not
getting involved.
Possible red card for Mancini after 41 minutes for SFP. Again I
can support a yellow card here but VAR wouldn’t have overturned
a red.
Other than that, a host of basic decisions called incorrectly.
Listed below to the best of my memory:
First Half:
Handball called against Dewsbury-Hall despite it being hit
against his face.
Incorrect fouls given against Dewsbury-Hall, Vardy, Ricardo,
Pellegrini and Karsdorp.
Second Half:
Missed yellow card for Evans for reckless foul from behind.
Incorrect fouls given against Dewsbury-Hall, Karsdorp and
Zaniolo.
Obvious errors when giving a goal kick instead of a corner
(Perez) and throw to Roma instead of Leicester (Justin).
Correct caution for Fofana and Maddison.
It must also be said he got the red card for Chris Evans after
the final whistle correct, assuming he has said something out of
turn.
Very disappointing for a UEFA semi final, albeit the lesser of
the competitions.
#Post#: 47888--------------------------------------------------
Re: Roma vs Leicester - Srjdan Jovanovic
DIR By: jacksamuel21
Date: May 5, 2022, 5:14 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Having watched that game I can confirm that it was a very poor
performance from all officials especially Jovanovic and AR1.
AR1 missed a clear offside at one point.
It felt like the whole game he seemed to ignore fouls then give
free kicks for things that shouldn’t have been free kicks.
Commentators and both players where confused by him.
AR1 gave a freekick when Vardy won the ball right in front of
him. Then gave a freekick when there was no contact whatsoever
with the player(also right in front of him)
Furthermore, there was a strange situation with the 40 that
ended up with a thrown being given initially but then a drop
ball was taken.
Then he stopped play put his hand in the air and then about 10
seconds later blew for half time and confused a few people
Really poor performance for me just like Orsato yesterday.
First time I have seen Jovanovic referee and he seemed unfit
almost and unable to keep up just like Orsato
#Post#: 47889--------------------------------------------------
Re: Roma vs Leicester - Srjdan Jovanovic
DIR By: jacksamuel21
Date: May 5, 2022, 5:15 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Ref95 link ---
>
> Mr Jovanovic had an extremely poor game and looked well out of
his depth in all honesty, without there being any major decisons
in the game. The only decisions that could have been considered
anywhere near ‘big decisions’ were:
>
> Penalty appeal for a foul on Fofana by Smalling after 3
minutes for a holding offence from a corner. Appeared to be a
clear foul, but a subjective decision and I can support VAR not
getting involved.
>
> Possible red card for Mancini after 41 minutes for SFP. Again
I can support a yellow card here but VAR wouldn’t have
overturned a red.
>
> Other than that, a host of basic decisions called incorrectly.
Listed below to the best of my memory:
> First Half:
> Handball called against Dewsbury-Hall despite it being hit
against his face.
> Incorrect fouls given against Dewsbury-Hall, Vardy, Ricardo,
Pellegrini and Karsdorp.
> Second Half:
> Missed yellow card for Evans for reckless foul from behind.
> Incorrect fouls given against Dewsbury-Hall, Karsdorp and
Zaniolo.
> Obvious errors when giving a goal kick instead of a corner
(Perez) and throw to Roma instead of Leicester (Justin).
> Correct caution for Fofana and Maddison.
>
> It must also be said he got the red card for Chris Evans after
the final whistle correct, assuming he has said something out of
turn.
>
> Very disappointing for a UEFA semi final, albeit the lesser of
the competitions.
>
--- End Quote ---
I think Evans won the ball and it was from the side- should be
play in for me. But if it’s a freekick it should be yellow.
#Post#: 47895--------------------------------------------------
Re: Roma vs Leicester - Srjdan Jovanovic
DIR By: Referee99
Date: May 6, 2022, 1:48 am
---------------------------------------------------------
I think everyone has covered points of throughout the game - the
most frustrating and disappointing thing about the whole
performance was how many ‘simple’ decisions he got wrong. If
it’s one or 2 then you can understand but when there is so many
then it’s not good enough
#Post#: 47897--------------------------------------------------
Re: Roma vs Leicester - Srjdan Jovanovic
DIR By: ARF
Date: May 6, 2022, 4:33 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Always amazes me the double standards within football between
players' performances and officials' performances, even within
our own refereeing community... a centre mid can't complete a
successful pass all game, or a striker can't get a single shot
on target, and it's 'unlucky' or 'a bad day at the office' - a
referee makes some incorrect decisions (whether objectively or
subjectively) and they're "the worst I've ever seen", "a
disgrace" etc. etc. Bemusing.
#Post#: 47900--------------------------------------------------
Re: Roma vs Leicester - Srjdan Jovanovic
DIR By: jacksamuel21
Date: May 6, 2022, 5:39 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: ARF link ---
>
> Always amazes me the double standards within football between
players' performances and officials' performances, even within
our own refereeing community... a centre mid can't complete a
successful pass all game, or a striker can't get a single shot
on target, and it's 'unlucky' or 'a bad day at the office' - a
referee makes some incorrect decisions (whether objectively or
subjectively) and they're "the worst I've ever seen", "a
disgrace" etc. etc. Bemusing.
>
--- End Quote ---
Its the number of simple decisions which he got wrong though,
and people do say thats the worse central midfield performance
of all time as well
*****************************************************
Page 1 of 2
DIR Next Page