DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       RateTheRef
  HTML https://ratetheref.createaforum.com
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       *****************************************************
   DIR Return to: General Discussion
       *****************************************************
       #Post#: 2801--------------------------------------------------
       Craig Hicks Walsall v Sunderland
   DIR By: robbieg
       Date: November 26, 2018, 11:56 am
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       Well there we go...…..
       A 50/50 ball between Lee Kinsella[ Walsall] and Max Power
       [already RCd twice this season for good reason] and the Red Card
       is out for Power  with the opposition player having both feet
       already off the ground as he comes in then rolls around
       theatrically to make the point before miraculously recovering
       after Power had departed.
       Hicks was in a perfectly good position to view the whole
       incident closely and his decision to send the Sunderland player
       off was truly dreadful.How on earth someone can get a decision
       so badly wrong is in my opinion incomprehensible.
       Both managers agreed it was never a yellow card let alone a
       red, so that shows just how wrong the decision was.....
       Quite rightly the RC was recinded today ,but that doesn't take
       away the injustice of it all.
       Has this referee caused problems elsewhere ?
       #Post#: 2804--------------------------------------------------
       Re: Craig Hicks Walsall v Sunderland
   DIR By: nemesis
       Date: November 26, 2018, 12:36 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       --- Quote from: robbieg link ---
       >
       > Well there we go...…..
       >
       > A 50/50 ball between Lee Kinsella[ Walsall] and Max Power
       [already RCd twice this season for good reason] and the Red Card
       is out for Power  with the opposition player having both feet
       already off the ground as he comes in then rolls around
       theatrically to make the point before miraculously recovering
       after Power had departed.
       > Hicks was in a perfectly good position to view the whole
       incident closely and his decision to send the Sunderland player
       off was truly dreadful.How on earth someone can get a decision
       so badly wrong is in my opinion incomprehensible.
       > Both managers agreed it was never a yellow card let alone a
       red, so that shows just how wrong the decision was.....
       >
       > Quite rightly the RC was recinded today ,but that doesn't take
       away the injustice of it all.
       >
       > Has this referee caused problems elsewhere ?
       >
       --- End Quote ---
       Massively out of his depth on his two visits to Roots Hall this
       season.
       Another one with a comfortable County FA job. They do seem to
       proliferate
       #Post#: 2808--------------------------------------------------
       Re: Craig Hicks Walsall v Sunderland
   DIR By: Skydank
       Date: November 26, 2018, 2:30 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       Plymouth v Peterborough last season..poor decisions leading to
       red card overturned on appeal
       #Post#: 2810--------------------------------------------------
       Re: Craig Hicks Walsall v Sunderland
   DIR By: TVOS
       Date: November 26, 2018, 2:44 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       --- Quote from: nemesis link ---
       >
       > [quote author=robbieg link=topic=335.msg2801#msg2801
       date=1543254988]
       > Well there we go...…..
       >
       > A 50/50 ball between Lee Kinsella[ Walsall] and Max Power
       [already RCd twice this season for good reason] and the Red Card
       is out for Power  with the opposition player having both feet
       already off the ground as he comes in then rolls around
       theatrically to make the point before miraculously recovering
       after Power had departed.
       > Hicks was in a perfectly good position to view the whole
       incident closely and his decision to send the Sunderland player
       off was truly dreadful.How on earth someone can get a decision
       so badly wrong is in my opinion incomprehensible.
       > Both managers agreed it was never a yellow card let alone a
       red, so that shows just how wrong the decision was.....
       >
       > Quite rightly the RC was recinded today ,but that doesn't take
       away the injustice of it all.
       >
       > Has this referee caused problems elsewhere ?
       >
       --- End Quote ---
       Massively out of his depth on his two visits to Roots Hall this
       season.
       Another one with a comfortable County FA job. They do seem to
       proliferate
       [/quote]
       Looking forward to reports of his performance at Oxford tomorrow
       and then he has a televised Welsh derby in the FA Cup on
       Saturday night...
       *****************************************************
       Page 1 of 1