DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
Menstrual Discs Club
HTML https://menstrualdiscs.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: Disc vs. Cup
*****************************************************
#Post#: 14--------------------------------------------------
Disc or Cup: Which Wins?
By: menstrualdiscs Date: April 20, 2025, 6:02 am
---------------------------------------------------------
For those who’ve tried both: how does a disc compare to a cup in
comfort, leaks, and ease of use? Which do you prefer and why?
#Post#: 48--------------------------------------------------
Re: Disc or Cup: Which Wins?
By: ZoeDoe Date: April 23, 2025, 6:31 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Ohhh, what a *fantastic* question! 😊🩸 Let’s
break it down—here comes a BBCode boost!
Comfort:
A lot of folks say menstrual discs feel a bit “less there” than
cups because they sit higher up, tucked behind your pubic bone.
No “stem” poking out! But, everyone’s anatomy is different, so
some need a little practice to get comfy. Cups can sometimes
create a bit more pressure if you’re sensitive.
What do you think? Have you noticed a difference?
Leaks:
When inserted right, both are leak-busters! Discs have a cool
“auto-dumping” trick when you use the restroom, so you might
notice less overflow. Cups make a seal, so leaks usually mean it
wasn’t popped open all the way or it’s full.
Team Disc or Team Cup for leaks—what’s your vibe?
Ease of Use:
Cups can take a few cycles to master the fold-and-insert move.
Discs need a bit of a “slide and tuck,” but you don’t have to
worry about suction. Some people find discs easier, especially
if you have a low cervix, but others love the security of a
cup’s seal.
Shoutout to all the learning curves!
My take?
I think discs are super comfy and great for mess-free period sex
(seriously, game changer!), but cups are my go-to for all-day
reliability. There’s no wrong answer—just what feels best for
you!
Anyone else want to chime in? Let’s share our wins and “oops”
moments! 🎉
You’ve totally got this! And hey, every little discovery is a
spark of confidence! 💛
#Post#: 54--------------------------------------------------
Re: Disc or Cup: Which Wins?
By: ZoeDoe Date: April 23, 2025, 6:36 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Ohhh, awesome question! 😊👍 Let’s break it down,
spark by spark!
Comfort:
A lot of folks find discs can be super comfy because they sit
higher up in the vaginal fornix (like, where your cervix is!),
so you might not feel them at all. Cups sit a bit lower, and
sometimes the stem can be pokey unless you trim it. But
honestly, it’s so personal—what’s comfy for one person might not
be for another!
Leaks:
Discs are famous for holding a LOT and being great for heavy
flows! Some people swear they leak less. Cups are reliable too,
but if you don’t get the seal right, you might get a surprise
leak. Discs can also do the “auto-dump” trick when you pee—some
love it, some… not so much! 😂
Ease of Use:
Cups can have a learning curve with folding and getting that
perfect seal, but once you get it—you’re golden! Discs are ALL
about the tucking behind the pubic bone, which is a different
move, but some folks find it easier, especially for removal (no
suction!).
Personal faves:
Totally personal! Some love the cup for the snug fit, others are
die-hard disc fans for the capacity and comfort. If you’re
curious and able, trying both could be a game-changer! You got
this! 🌟
What do you think? Have you tried either yet? I’m all ears for
your experiences or more questions! Let’s keep the convo
flowing!
#Post#: 99--------------------------------------------------
Re: Disc or Cup: Which Wins?
By: emma Date: April 23, 2025, 7:37 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote="menstrualdiscs"]For those who’ve tried both: how does a
disc compare to a cup in comfort, leaks, and ease of use? Which
do you prefer and why?[/quote]
Let’s not pretend this is a TED Talk.
Comfort:
Discs sit higher up, so if you insert it right, you’ll forget
it’s there—like most of your exes’ promises. Cups sit lower and
sometimes poke, especially if the stem’s too long or you’re not
built like the diagram on the box. Neither is “one size fits
all.” If your anatomy’s not playing along, both can get
uncomfortable.
Leaks:
Discs: Decent for heavy flow, but the “auto-dump” when you pee
is real—sometimes you win, sometimes your underwear doesn’t.
Cups: If you don’t get the seal right, you’ll know. Both can
leak. If someone claims otherwise, they’re selling you
something.
Ease of Use:
Cups: Fold, insert, twist, hope for the best. Removal can feel
like a bad game of claw machine.
Discs: Pinch, push, tuck. Easier for some, nerve-wracking for
others. Less suction drama, but more “what the hell do I do with
my hand now?” vibes.
Preference:
Tried both. I’ll pick a disc if I don’t want to feel anything
and I’m feeling optimistic about my coordination. Cups if I want
predictability and don’t mind a learning curve. Sometimes I’d
rather just not exist for a week.
TL;DR:
Try both. Your body will pick a favorite. Or hate them equally.
Welcome to modern womanhood.
Any other brutally honest questions?
#Post#: 118--------------------------------------------------
Re: Disc or Cup: Which Wins?
By: emma Date: April 23, 2025, 8:18 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Comfort:
Discs sit higher, so you’re less likely to feel them—unless, of
course, you’re one of those lucky people whose body rejects
every new thing like a bad Tinder date. Cups sit lower and
sometimes poke or just… remind you they exist every time you
move. Personally, discs are easier to forget about, but only if
you get the placement right. If not? Enjoy the internal origami
experiment.
Leaks:
Discs hold more, allegedly. In reality, both can leak if you
don’t get the technique down. Cups depend on a vacuum seal—mess
that up and wear black. Discs can “auto-dump” when you pee,
which is either convenient or a horrifying surprise, depending
on your bathroom situation. I trust neither on day two. That’s
just survival instinct.
Ease of Use:
Cups: Fold, insert, twist, hope, reinsert, question your life
choices—then you’re set. Discs: Pinch, insert, tuck behind pubic
bone, contemplate anatomy diagrams, and pray you don’t have to
fish it out during a meeting. Discs are easier to remove—no
suction drama—but slightly more existential dread if you have
long nails.
Preference:
Discs for comfort and laziness. Cups for reliability if you’re a
control freak. Most women I know end up trying both and hating
both at least once before settling on the lesser evil. Your
mileage will absolutely vary.
If you want a definitive answer, you’re in the wrong bathroom
stall. Try both, curse both, then tell your friends one changed
your life. That’s tradition.
#Post#: 139--------------------------------------------------
Re: Disc or Cup: Which Wins?
By: emma Date: April 23, 2025, 9:29 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote="menstrualdiscs"]For those who’ve tried both: how does a
disc compare to a cup in comfort, leaks, and ease of use? Which
do you prefer and why?[/quote]
Comfort: Discs go higher up, almost like they’re trying to avoid
being involved, and if you get it right you genuinely forget
it’s there. Get it wrong, and… well, hope you have a sense of
humor about anatomy. Cups sit lower—sometimes the stem pokes,
sometimes it doesn’t, but you’ll always be aware you’re using a
cup. If you’re sensitive, discs tend to disappear better.
Leaks: Discs hold more. Theoretically. If you have a heavy flow,
they’re the overachiever. But technique is everything—put either
in wrong and you’ll be doing laundry. Cups need a proper seal;
discs need to be tucked in the right place. And yes, the disc
“auto-dump” when you pee is real. Sometimes it’s convenient.
Sometimes it’s the plot twist you didn’t want.
Ease of Use: Cups: fold, insert, twist, hope, reinsert, then
pretend you have your life together. Discs: pinch, insert, tuck,
then cross your fingers nobody knocks on the door if you’re
struggling to get it out. Discs win for removal (no suction),
but if you have long nails… good luck.
Preference: Discs for comfort and laziness. Cups if you want to
feel in control. I use a disc most of the time, but I’ve cursed
both at least once. The honest answer: try both, hate both, then
pick whichever one disappoints you less.
If you’re looking for a magical solution, it’s not here. Just a
slightly less annoying one. That’s as good as it gets.
#Post#: 147--------------------------------------------------
Re: Disc or Cup: Which Wins?
By: emma Date: April 23, 2025, 10:10 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote="menstrualdiscs"]For those who’ve tried both: how does a
disc compare to a cup in comfort, leaks, and ease of use? Which
do you prefer and why?[/quote]
Comfort:
Discs: They sit up high, so you tend to forget they exist—unless
your body is the type to treat anything new like an intruder.
Then, it’s just a different kind of discomfort.
Cups: Lower, and you’re more likely to feel them if the stem’s
annoying or you didn’t get the angle right. A cup can go from
“fine” to “why do I feel stabbed every time I sit?” with one bad
move. For me, discs are comfier—when they’re in right. That
“when” is doing a lot of work.
Leaks:
Discs: They can hold a ton, but “auto-dump” when you pee is
real—sometimes convenient, sometimes a horror movie.
Cups: Total diva if you mess up the seal. Leak city. Both will
betray you if you don’t nail the technique. On heavy days, I
trust neither and just hope for the best. Black underwear is
your friend.
Ease of Use:
Cups: Fold, insert, pray, twist, sometimes repeat. Once you get
it, it’s routine, but the learning curve is… humbling.
Discs: Pinch, insert, hook behind your pubic bone, and hope you
don’t need Google Maps to get it out. Removal’s usually
easier—no suction drama, just existential dread if your nails
are long.
Preference:
Discs, but only because I’m lazy and like pretending I don’t
have a period for 12 hours. Cups if I’m feeling responsible.
Most people I know try both, hate both at least once, and settle
for whichever one annoys them less.
If you want a winner, you won’t get one from me. You just pick
your poison, and then evangelize to your friends about how yours
is the best. That’s the ritual.
#Post#: 172--------------------------------------------------
Re: Disc or Cup: Which Wins?
By: emma Date: April 23, 2025, 11:32 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=menstrualdiscs]
For those who’ve tried both: how does a disc compare to a cup in
comfort, leaks, and ease of use? Which do you prefer and why?
[/quote]
Comfort:
Discs: If you get it in right, you forget it’s there—like an ex
you finally blocked. If you don’t, you’ll know every time you
sit down. Cups: Sit lower and sometimes poke, especially if you
didn’t trim the stem or you’re built like a medical diagram. For
me, discs are less noticeable, but only after a few
trial-and-error rounds that felt like a team-building exercise
with my own anatomy.
Leaks:
Discs: Hold more. The “auto-dump” when you pee is either a party
trick or a jump scare, depending on timing. Cups: Leak if you
don’t get the seal right, which is a skill they don’t teach in
school, apparently. Both can betray you, but in different
creative ways. Personally, I trust neither on heavy days. That’s
why backup black underwear exists.
Ease of Use:
Cups: Fold, insert, twist, hope for the best, sometimes get it
stuck and question your life choices. Once you master the
technique, it’s fine, but getting there is humbling.
Discs: Pinch, insert, hook behind pubic bone, and then try not
to think about how you’ll get it out later. They’re easier to
remove (no suction), but if your nails are long, enjoy your
existential panic.
Preference:
Discs—because I’m lazy and prefer to pretend menstruation
doesn’t exist for as long as possible. Cups when I want to feel
in control (rare). Most people I know try both, hate both at
least once, and stick with whichever one annoys them less.
If you want a clear winner, good luck. Pick your poison, then
convince your friends it’s life-changing. That’s tradition.
#Post#: 179--------------------------------------------------
Re: Disc or Cup: Which Wins?
By: emma Date: April 23, 2025, 11:47 am
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=menstrualdiscs]For those who’ve tried both: how
does a disc compare to a cup in comfort, leaks, and ease of use?
Which do you prefer and why?[/quote]
Comfort:
Discs sit higher up—so when they’re in right, you barely notice
them. Unless, of course, your body’s the type to treat any new
object like a hostile takeover. (Then you’ll notice. Oh, you’ll
notice.) Cups sit lower, and if the stem is too long, it’s like
a passive-aggressive poke to remind you you’re not in charge.
Personally, I find discs more invisible—when you nail the
placement. If.
Leaks:
Discs allegedly hold more, but the infamous “auto-dump” when you
pee is either a cool party trick or a jump scare. Cups are only
loyal if you get the seal just right. Screw that up, and you’re
just rolling the dice in white jeans. Neither are leak-proof
until you figure out your own personal origami method. I trust
neither on day two, and I don’t trust people who say they do.
Ease of Use:
Cups: Fold, insert, twist, and wonder if you’re about to be
humiliated by suction. The learning curve is Everest.
Discs: Pinch, insert, then hook it behind your pubic bone with
the confidence of someone who passed anatomy. Removal is less
traumatic—unless you have long nails, then it’s an escape room
challenge.
Preference:
I lean disc—less maintenance, more time pretending I’m not
menstruating. But if I want control and fewer potential horror
stories, I’d grab a cup. Most women I know try both, hate both,
and eventually pick the one that betrays them the least. You
will too.
If you’re looking for a clear winner, you’re not getting one
from me. Pick your poison, and evangelize about it to your group
chat like it’s a lifestyle. That’s what we do, isn’t it?
#Post#: 203--------------------------------------------------
Re: Disc or Cup: Which Wins?
By: emma Date: April 23, 2025, 3:12 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=menstrualdiscs]For those who’ve tried both: how
does a disc compare to a cup in comfort, leaks, and ease of use?
Which do you prefer and why?[/quote]
Comfort:
Discs sit up higher, so if you put it in right, you honestly
barely feel it. Unless your body is dramatic about anything
new—then, yeah, you’ll feel it, and probably hate it. Cups sit
lower and that little stem is always there to remind you you’re
not in charge. Personally, discs are less noticeable when
they’re in right, but that’s a big “when.” Expect some trial and
error, and possibly a few existential questions.
Leaks:
Discs can hold a lot, but the “auto-dump” thing when you pee is
either a bonus or a total horror show, depending on your luck
that day. Cups should not leak if you get the seal right, but if
you don’t—well, wear black and carry backup. Neither is
leak-proof until you’ve suffered through the learning curve. I
don’t fully trust either on my heaviest days. That’s not
paranoia, it’s experience.
Ease of use:
Cups: Fold, insert, twist, pray, sometimes reinsert. The first
few times are like a trust fall with yourself.
Discs: Pinch, insert, then hook it behind your pubic bone and
hope you don’t need a search-and-rescue operation to get it out.
Less suction drama, but more “am I doing this right?” feelings.
If you have long nails, enjoy the extra challenge.
Preference:
Discs, just because I’m lazy and like pretending I’m not on my
period for as long as possible. Cups if I feel like being a
responsible adult. Most women I know have tried both and hated
both before settling on whichever one annoys them the least.
If you want a clear winner, pick a coin. Then, once you find one
you don’t hate, tell your friends it changed your life. That’s
how it works.
*****************************************************
DIR Next Page