DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
know the way
HTML https://knowtheway.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: ARTICLES AGAINST ISLAM
*****************************************************
#Post#: 160--------------------------------------------------
REJOINDER OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD VS JESUS CHRIST PART 3 OF 4
By: Captshittu Date: November 17, 2017, 12:25 am
---------------------------------------------------------
REJOINDER OF TEACHINGS OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD VS JESUS CHRIST PART
3 OF 4
PART (3 of 4)
TABLE ELEVEN
Muhammad had sex with a 9 year old child, (Sahih Muslim 3309,
Bukhari 58:236)
Jesus never.
In QUR'AN 68:4 Allah said Muhammad (pbuh) has the greatest
attitude.
Let take look into it from different aspects:
1. LEGALITY:- simply means LAWFULNESS, this is something that is
lawful under a community or society, that's if someone perform
anything that's legal under a community or society there should
be no sin or punishment for it.
For example, if we use the case muslims in china during Ramadan,
legally they are not allowed but religion allow them to fast
that means u are free not to fast, and if u do so and u have
been caught they can punish d person.
Now where the explanation came from, in India the law permit 18
years to marry (if anybody marry girl less than 18 years old he
can be classified as paedophile or child abuser and he can be
punished according to law), in America 16 years old can marry
legally that's means anything less than that year shall be
punished according to law, in ancient Rome, Roman empirer was
allowed according to constitution 12 years old girl to marry and
14 for boy and 20 is classified as late marriage, In Nigeria
minimum to marry is 18 years (although Nigeria is less concern
abt that), in the United States, back in 1880, in the state of
Delaware, the minimum age for marriage was 7yrs, In California
it was 10,In some Islamic States girl is allowed to marry less
than 10 years (if she reach puberty stage)💐
YOU CAN GOOGLE IT👌
According to all these, since it is legalized to marry less than
10years in islamic states it is not a sin according to legal age
for marriage in Saudi Arabia for prophet Muhammed to marry
Aishat at that age.
2. RELIGION:- This is the believe according to Faith, every
religion has do and undo, any body that transgress this rules
shall be punished from God. For example some countries legalised
adultery, public sex, homosexuality etc, but no religion accept
this, if anyone try it he or she shall be punished by God.
In Christianity it is allowed to marry (when the girl is suit to
marry and reach the puberty stage) Before 1929, church of
england ministers could marry 12yrs old girls in Britain, Up
till 1983, catholic canon laws permitted priests to marry off
brides at the age of 12. In traditional way is also allowed to
marry when the girl is suit to marry, Islam is allowed to marry
as well in as much the girl is suit for marriage, and reach the
puberty stage. And it's confirmed by hadith that Aishat is suit
for marriage and reach puberty stage before prophet Muhammed
meet her bcs the hadith was narrated by her with happiness and
it was recorded that she is abt to marry at that time before
abubakr (her father, and prophet's friend) gave it to the
prophet and she accepted, and it was recorded that she use to
teach people abt religion that means she is not a kid at that
time. That's to say prophet is not guilty according to religion.
3. MORALITY:- Recognition of the distinction between good and
evil or between right and wrong; respect for and obedience to
the rules of right conduct; the mental disposition or
characteristic of behaving in a manner intended to produce
morally good results. OR A set of social rules, customs,
traditions, beliefs, or practices which specify proper,
acceptable forms of conduct. In term morality there are some
conditions that should be considered bcus yoruba says "bayii lan
se Nilewa eewo ibomiran ni". Meaning one man food is another man
poison, for example parking of cars beside road might not be
prosecuted in Nigeria, but if try that in developed country u
might be prosecuted, and also wearing of shoot in London is
normal thing, but in India it must be by an occasion. Now the
question is "WAS IT MORALLY ACCEPTED IN SAUDI ARABIA THEN?" NOW:
let take look into it with this aspect, Jesus was born without
father which is against the moral and believe of Jews then
that's why they call him bastard but God said he want to use it
as for sign for them so that they can believe (this was against
the moral of Jews but accepted by God), and if we can check it
from history, Why is it that during the days of Quraysh, they
called the Rasulullah (SAW): Magician, madman, and the likes
(bcus his teachings against their gods and his miracles) but
NEVER called him a **** They never raised any question about his
marriage to Aisha (R.A), Because it was NORMAL at that time and
accepted by their morals that, girls at that age were suitable
for marriage at that time. And it was recorded that When
Sofiyyah bint Huyay was married to the Muhammed (SAW), she was
just 17yrs old? And that was her THIRD marriage, She was
initially married to Salam ibn abi Haqiq and later to Kinanah
ibn abi Haqiq, that means her age at first marriage will be at d
range of that, With all these messenger of Allah is not faulty
in marrying Aisha at that age bcus it was morally accepted.
4. CHANGES:- means replace OR the process of becoming different.
Law can change, religion law can change and moral can also
change, stage of puberty can change as well, these happen bcs of
some conditions, For example It was normal before (in yoruba) to
wear agbada for young ones but now it look local that means it
changed, Now what causes changes of puberty stage?: Atmosphere,
Surroundings, climate, birth etc. And scientists said that
closer to the point of equator the stage of puberty is earlier,
which says that the stage of puberty is earlier that time.
5. HISTORY:- Although this doesn't matter a lot but we have to
know it for better understanding.
-According to the catholic encyclopedia, Mary the mother of
Jesus was 12 when she married the 99 years old Joseph.
-According to Rashis commentary Isaac was thirty-seven years
old, and at that time, Rebecca was born. He waited for her until
she would be fit for marital relations-three years-and then
married her- [From Gen. Rabbah 57:1
According to all these aspects we can see that it is suitable to
marry 9 yrs old girl at that time either by legality or by
religion, morality, and others. It is for me to say it but is
Allah for better understanding, may Almighty Allah give us the
wisdom and understanding. If u can reasoning with these u can
see that Aishat was suitable for marriage at that time but the
problem is just lack of understanding👌
TABLE TWELVE
Muhammad ordered the murder of women. (Ibn Ishaq 819,995)
Jesus never harmed a woman.
.
Ibn ishaq is not authentic hadith and many hadith scholars
reported many things about the authenticity of ibn ishaq. E.g
Imam Malik-- [lived closest in the time to the life of Prophet
Muhammad of all the collectors of the hadith (Bukhari, Muslim,
Abu Dawud, etc), Imam Malik was a hadith scholar]Imam Malik
called Ibn Ishaq a liar and an imposter for writing false
stories about Prophet Muhammad. Imam Malik has said that Ibn
Ishaq "reports traditions on the authority of the
Jews".(Kadhdhab and Dajjal min al-dajajila. Uyun al-athar, I,
16-7)
Moreover there is no report hadith in 819 and all the hadith is
922 (not up to 995). CHRISTIANS AND LIE
Allah says in Q21:107 "We have not sent you (o Muhammad) but as
mercy to the worlds". There is no where in the history where
prophet Muhammad (saw) harm not to talk of kill woman that's why
he said "Prohibition against Killing Women and Children in
Military Expeditions" (Maliks Muwatta 021:10)
TABLE THIRTEEN
Muhammad said " O you who believe! Fight those of the
unbelievers who are near to you and let them find in you
hardness." (Qur'an 3:110)
Jesus said "Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the
Earth" (Matthew 5:5)
Q3:110 "Ye are the best of peoples, evolved for mankind,
enjoining what is right, forbidding what is wrong, and believing
in Allah. If only the People of the Book had faith, it were best
for them: among them are some who have faith, but most of them
are perverted transgressors."
As we can see that the verse is not the same with what they
wrote about prophet Muhammad (pbuh).
See what Jesus said (according to gospel writers) in
Matthew 5:22 "whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger
of hell fire."
But unfortunately Jesus called people fool In
Luke 11:40 "JESUS SAID Ye FOOL'S, did not He that made that
which is without make that which is within also"
TABLE FOURTEEN
Muhammad ordered 65 military campaigns and raids in his last
10years. (Ibn Ishaq)
Jesus ordered no military campaigns, nor offered any approval of
war or violence.
As we explained in (table 13) on the authenticity of ibn ishaq
hadith and there is no specific number of the hadith (this also
shows sign of lie).
More explanation on military issue during the time of prophet
Since there is no specific number of the hadith we can not trust
their claim.
Islam was not just a religion but a Nation. And was surrounded
by enemy Nations.
No arguement saying a Nation in those Century meant
Military-Regime because no group can be a Nation then without
War. And prophet Muhammad (saw) was not just religion leader but
also political leader (which lead all Muslims in the whole
world), while Jesus was not political leader and has no
authority in isreal and according to Bible if Jesus can be a
leader he will do so bcus of what he commanded his followers in
Luke 19:27 "But those mine enemies, which would not that I
should reign over them, bring hither, and slay them before me."
AND Luke 9:28 He took Peter and John and James, along with him
to guard him. after he has order for swords in Luke 22:36.
And there is no where in Quran where Allah command prophet to go
and destroy any nation in Quran but let here from bible and see:
1SAMUEL15:3 "Now go and kill Amalek, and utterly destroy all
that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman,
infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass". This is
command of God to Samuel
TABLE FIFTEEN
Muhammad killed captives taken in battle. (Ibn Ishaq 451)
Jesus never took captives; never killed anyone.
We have explained in (table 13) on the authenticity of ibn ishaq
hadith. Alihamdulilahi ibn ishaq 451 didn't tell story of
prophet Muhammad (saw) but uthman and it didn't talk about
killing captives
Let see biblical proof
Deut. 21:10 "When thou goes forth to war against thine enemies,
and the thy God hath delivered them into thine hands, and thou
hast taken them captive"
TABLE SIXTEEN
Muhammad encouraged his men to **** enslaved women. (Abu Dawud
2150, Qur'an 4:24)
Jesus never encouraged ****; never enslaved women.
When Christians want to translate this hadith they will
mistranslate it in order to suit them, while the hadith never
mentioned such
Q4:24 "And all married women except those whom your right hands
possess (this is) Allah's ordinance to you, and lawful for you
are (all women) besides those, provided that you seek (them)
with your property, taking (them) in marriage not committing
fornication. Then as to those whom you profit by, give them
their dowries as appointed; and there is no blame on you about
what you mutually agree after what is appointed; surely Allah is
Knowing, Wise."
What Allah mentioned is marry not ****, even it's mentioned that
we should not commit fornication.
CLICK ON PART 4
HTML https://knowtheway.createaforum.com/articles-against-islam/rejoinder-of-prophet-muhammad-vs-jesus-christ/?prev_next=next#new
KEEP SHARING TO OTHERS
*****************************************************