DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
Haxball Club Divisionals
HTML https://hcd.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: HCD Rulebook Suggestions
*****************************************************
#Post#: 5846--------------------------------------------------
Draft and Keepers
By: Cole72 Date: March 16, 2013, 12:17 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Starting season 5, anyone who signs up for the draft CANNOT be a
keeper, therefore all team members are highly advised to speak
to their GMs before signing up for the draft, because once you
sign up for the draft it cannot be reversed.
This is a rule in SPHB, and it works fine. It also avoids
situations like that of Iguana Troll/Barca-Kes, so that way
people know exactly what they're getting into when signing up
for the draft.
#Post#: 5849--------------------------------------------------
Re: Draft and Keepers
By: Really Date: March 16, 2013, 12:54 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Yeah,this can be a rule.
#Post#: 5850--------------------------------------------------
Re: Draft and Keepers
By: Canni Date: March 16, 2013, 1:18 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Also...2 keepers for div A teams (includes div B team that moves
up to div A) and 3 for div B (with relegated div A team)
>letting same teams stack every season
#Post#: 5853--------------------------------------------------
Re: Draft and Keepers
By: Lord of Fail Date: March 16, 2013, 1:51 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=undrctrl link=topic=1201.msg5850#msg5850
date=1363457925]
Also...2 keepers for div A teams (includes div B team that moves
up to div A) and 3 for div B (with relegated div A team)
>letting same teams stack every season
[/quote]
this league is based on EPL. it is not centered around the draft
and the concept is a pratically complete redraft displeases me.
For season 5 i am consiering reducing the roster limit to 7, the
keeper limit to 3, and the draft rounds to 4.
#Post#: 5854--------------------------------------------------
Re: Draft and Keepers
By: Really Date: March 16, 2013, 1:54 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Lord of Fail link=topic=1201.msg5853#msg5853
date=1363459903]
[quote author=undrctrl link=topic=1201.msg5850#msg5850
date=1363457925]
Also...2 keepers for div A teams (includes div B team that moves
up to div A) and 3 for div B (with relegated div A team)
>letting same teams stack every season
[/quote]
this league is based on EPL. it is not centered around the draft
and the concept is a pratically complete redraft displeases me.
For season 5 i am consiering reducing the roster limit to 7, the
keeper limit to 3, and the draft rounds to 4.
[/quote] So then there are 4 rounds per each draft (divisional)
or 4 rounds in total ( all divisions). I just want to clarify.
#Post#: 5858--------------------------------------------------
Re: Draft and Keepers
By: Cole72 Date: March 16, 2013, 2:36 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Lof, that is just about THE most autistic thing ever. The way
you are saying you want it to be is basically saying you want
the same team to win every single season. BS.
#Post#: 5859--------------------------------------------------
Re: Draft and Keepers
By: Lord of Fail Date: March 16, 2013, 2:40 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Really link=topic=1201.msg5854#msg5854
date=1363460050]
[quote author=Lord of Fail link=topic=1201.msg5853#msg5853
date=1363459903]
[quote author=undrctrl link=topic=1201.msg5850#msg5850
date=1363457925]
Also...2 keepers for div A teams (includes div B team that moves
up to div A) and 3 for div B (with relegated div A team)
>letting same teams stack every season
[/quote]
this league is based on EPL. it is not centered around the draft
and the concept is a pratically complete redraft displeases me.
For season 5 i am consiering reducing the roster limit to 7, the
keeper limit to 3, and the draft rounds to 4.
[/quote] So then there are 4 rounds per each draft (divisional)
or 4 rounds in total ( all divisions). I just want to clarify.
[/quote]
it would be 4 rounds per division
#Post#: 5860--------------------------------------------------
Re: Draft and Keepers
By: Lord of Fail Date: March 16, 2013, 2:41 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Cole 72 link=topic=1201.msg5858#msg5858
date=1363462585]
Lof, that is just about THE most autistic thing ever. The way
you are saying you want it to be is basically saying you want
the same team to win every single season. BS.
[/quote]
if the roster limit is lowered to 7 and the keeper limit is
reduced to 3, it would be hard for a team to be so stacked
unless 3 players can carry the team. In that case, other GMs
should try to get some great players to sign up
#Post#: 5867--------------------------------------------------
Re: Draft and Keepers
By: Cole72 Date: March 16, 2013, 3:03 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Lord of Fail link=topic=1201.msg5860#msg5860
date=1363462899]
[quote author=Cole 72 link=topic=1201.msg5858#msg5858
date=1363462585]
Lof, that is just about THE most autistic thing ever. The way
you are saying you want it to be is basically saying you want
the same team to win every single season. BS.
[/quote]
if the roster limit is lowered to 7 and the keeper limit is
reduced to 3, it would be hard for a team to be so stacked
unless 3 players can carry the team. In that case, other GMs
should try to get some great players to sign up
[/quote]
>3 ppl carry a team in a 3v3 leeg
That's like saying that in the epl a team should only be allowed
to keep 11 players because then it would be hard for the same
team to win every year, unless 11 people can carry a team.
#Post#: 5870--------------------------------------------------
Re: Draft and Keepers
By: Lord of Fail Date: March 16, 2013, 3:15 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
[quote author=Cole 72 link=topic=1201.msg5867#msg5867
date=1363464201]
[quote author=Lord of Fail link=topic=1201.msg5860#msg5860
date=1363462899]
[quote author=Cole 72 link=topic=1201.msg5858#msg5858
date=1363462585]
Lof, that is just about THE most autistic thing ever. The way
you are saying you want it to be is basically saying you want
the same team to win every single season. BS.
[/quote]
if the roster limit is lowered to 7 and the keeper limit is
reduced to 3, it would be hard for a team to be so stacked
unless 3 players can carry the team. In that case, other GMs
should try to get some great players to sign up
[/quote]
>3 ppl carry a team in a 3v3 leeg
That's like saying that in the epl a team should only be allowed
to keep 11 players because then it would be hard for the same
team to win every year, unless 11 people can carry a team.
[/quote]
cole, i guarantee you that if an EPL team only had 11 players
they would not be in the EPL for very long.
of a HCD team has only 3 good players, they will have no depth
and will lose p much every game that theur 3 top players do not
show.
i will not reduce the keeper limit ever to less than 3, that
would just be stupid
*****************************************************
DIR Next Page