DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
Harry Potter Forever
HTML https://harrypotterforever.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: General...
*****************************************************
#Post#: 1129--------------------------------------------------
Harry Potter vs. Twilight
By: severus4ever Date: December 30, 2013, 3:28 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
I know I know. In a few minutes, this topic is going to get
crazy with all the attacks and defenses of Twilight. I had to
move posts here from the Hunger games board, topic Hunger Games
vs. Harry Potter, because it had a tiny thing about Twilight not
being worthy enough to be compared to Harry Potter.So discuss
all you want, try not to curse, and keep this PG-13 guys. Here
is my view about it, J.K Rowling wrote a better love story about
Snily in one chapter, Than Stephen Myers did in all 5 books.
Just stating the facts.
#Post#: 1130--------------------------------------------------
Re: Harry Potter vs. Twilight
By: crystal58 Date: December 30, 2013, 3:32 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
I happen to be a fan of Twilight and will ruefully defend it
from comments. I love Harry Potter, and I love Twilight equally.
There are so many criticisms of Twilight's dramatic story, but I
happen to enjoy reading the series. The love story that J.K
Rowling wrote is one of the saddest and beautiful I have
happened to read, but it isn't better than the ones Stephenie
Myer wrote. Most people are just big critics and judge Twilight
differently because of the Twilight films in which Kristen
Stewart happened to star in.
#Post#: 1131--------------------------------------------------
Re: Harry Potter vs. Twilight
By: ForeverPeeves Date: December 30, 2013, 3:50 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
It is like impossible for you to be a fan of harry potter AND
twilight at the same time. Either your just pretending to like
one of them or something, because by default, twilight fans and
harry potter fans are born rivals. +...it is not true that
people judge Twilight because of the films, people naturally
hate the series. It's not because of the Edward and Jacob
stereotype (well, maybe it is a little bit) that cause people to
view it differently. AND please don't get me started with
Kristen Stewart, arrghhh I'm going to lose my mind. She is
gorgeous and all, but she doesn't know how to act carefully,
maybe that's why they gave her the role of Bella: a self
conceited, relying, annoying, fake, piece of nothing. Sorry, but
the truth lies in my post.
#Post#: 1133--------------------------------------------------
Re: Harry Potter vs. Twilight
By: NimbusSpirit Date: January 1, 2014, 11:09 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Um, yeah, proud Potterhead and very anti-Twilight myself. But I
disagree that you can't be a fan of both - many of my friends
are (I have had many a debate with them in which I've told them
how much I think it sucks; they got the picture eventually).
What I really love to read are the arguments some fans get out
as to why Twilight is better than Harry Potter. My particular
favourite is "JK Rowling copied Stephenie Meyer", in regards to
the very weak link between Sirius Black, an animagus dog, and
Jacob Black, a werewolf. Apparently JK stole the surname and the
power from Stephenie. Point: Sirius is first mentioned in a book
in 1997; Jacob, not until 2005. Case and point. Always makes me
laugh, that one.
#Post#: 1134--------------------------------------------------
Re: Harry Potter vs. Twilight
By: hermione4ever Date: January 1, 2014, 1:26 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Starting out the new year with a big HP vs. Twilight debate? :D
#Post#: 1332--------------------------------------------------
Re: Harry Potter vs. Twilight
By: Gusaphinya Date: December 6, 2017, 4:12 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Read the content on this site. I get a lot of new knowledge.
#Post#: 1333--------------------------------------------------
Re: Harry Potter vs. Twilight
By: Slimnut Date: December 28, 2017, 12:47 am
---------------------------------------------------------
I can not compare it. I think it's a different genre. But if it
likes. I like Harry Potter more.
*****************************************************