DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
FF The Werewolf Game
HTML https://fftwg.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: General Discussion
*****************************************************
#Post#: 1420--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG Bidding Topic (Voting: Ancient Rome, Beauty and the
Beast, Pandemic)
DIR By: ZechAkari
Date: April 30, 2020, 4:15 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
why is the third one so vague
#Post#: 1421--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG Bidding Topic (Voting: Ancient Rome, Beauty and the
Beast, Pandemic)
DIR By: lena
Date: April 30, 2020, 4:16 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
hard no on ancient rome & BATB - fuck role renames to fit the
theme
also no on pandemic - pathogen looks way too easy to achieve the
goal as long as they don't fuckin die N1 also it's just too
ToS-y for my taste.
#Post#: 1422--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG Bidding Topic (Voting: Fool Me Once, Last Will and
Testament, Mountainous)
DIR By: ColtsFan18
Date: April 30, 2020, 4:16 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: Nickito link ---
>
> 1 - Wolves are underpowered with only 2 of them and 4 Seers,
and none of them are disguised, so no.
> 3 - no, like this is a boring role list. We only play what, 2
games a month? and we're wasting one of them on that?
>
> The middle one is a decent role list I guess, and having Wills
instead of Last Posts is interesting sure. However if Janitor
can clean one person each night why not just clean the person
that's being killed? Suddenly, there's not much of a point in
having Wills. Make Janitor Wolf only have 2 cleans and I'd
change from no to yes personally. Also, Janitor Wolf needs a
better name, "Janitor" is too sophisticated for a werewolf
>
--- End Quote ---
yeah probably would do that
#Post#: 1423--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG Bidding Topic (Voting: Ancient Rome, Beauty and the
Beast, Pandemic)
DIR By: Vinnie927
Date: April 30, 2020, 4:19 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
No for first and third bids bc Knot Expert
No for second bid bc of banning roleclaiming
#Post#: 1424--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG Bidding Topic (Voting: Ancient Rome, Beauty and the
Beast, Pandemic)
DIR By: xX_4vY_5i0nN4cH_Xx
Date: April 30, 2020, 4:19 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
ancient rome - there are some decent ideas here, but for the
most part this is a pretty standard TWG rolelist with reskinned
roles. also, gladiator is pretty much fucked in current
metagame. leaning no.
beauty and the beast - an almost-guaranteed three people dying
per night is almost automatic no for me.
pandemic - i actually like this one. pathogen appears a slight
bit OP at first glance, but town of salem has a very similarly
balanced role which hasn't been super OP so i'm not too worried.
leaning yes.
#Post#: 1426--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG Bidding Topic (Voting: Ancient Rome, Beauty and the
Beast, Pandemic)
DIR By: Le_Shrub
Date: April 30, 2020, 4:26 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Aww I thought banning roleclaiming would be fun because it's our
current meta :( I understand the too much death thing though.
I really don't dislike any of the rolelists though? I personally
don't have a problem with role renames, and the pandemic seems
fine to me (except maybe "choose your color"? Idk) I'm saying
yes to all, probably in the minority here though.
#Post#: 1427--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG Bidding Topic (Voting: Ancient Rome, Beauty and the
Beast, Pandemic)
DIR By: ZechAkari
Date: April 30, 2020, 4:27 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
im with shrub yes to all
second one is different, id personally like to see how it plays
out
third one, do they know if theyre infected? if not, pathogen can
make big mistake and choose blue and when seer seers someone
whos supposed to be green, and they say "yo wtf im infected dont
visit me so pathogen no win"
#Post#: 1430--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG Bidding Topic (Voting: Ancient Rome, Beauty and the
Beast, Pandemic)
DIR By: leia
Date: April 30, 2020, 4:29 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Ancient Rome- No, because rip Gladiator, how are they supposed
to know who their target is? Do they get hints or something?
Does their target know? It seems like just luck.
Beauty and the Beast- This really confuses me- 3 factions and no
role claiming? 3 faction games can be certainly interesting, but
no role claiming makes it really complicated, and I don't like
the idea of no role claiming to begin with because that's so
much of the game. Also, what happens if you don't get rid of the
wolves first? Who wins then? Is it just a normal game then?
Probably going with no, but explain some more and with edits I'd
maybe say yes.
Pandemic- I'm pretty sure we've played this before and I
cohosted with KKE? Not interested in playing it again, a No from
me. Also the pathologist works really slowly, there's almost no
point in having them "check", it'd be much more effective to
only cure.
#Post#: 1431--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG Bidding Topic (Voting: Ancient Rome, Beauty and the
Beast, Pandemic)
DIR By: Penguin022
Date: April 30, 2020, 4:31 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
no to ancient rome bc the gladiator is gonna lose
no to beauty and the beast bc i dont think it would work and
wolves like slightly UP
no to last one bc i don't like the cop being in this game and
seems unbalanced overall
#Post#: 1432--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG Bidding Topic (Voting: Ancient Rome, Beauty and the
Beast, Pandemic)
DIR By: ZechAkari
Date: April 30, 2020, 4:32 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
ok ancient rome is mine and gladiator is a real role (bounty
hunter) and i thought it would work fine in this game and i put
knot expert because i needed a town pop
*****************************************************
Page 6 of 10
DIR Previous Page
DIR Next Page