DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
FF The Werewolf Game
HTML https://fftwg.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: The Werewolf Game
*****************************************************
#Post#: 245--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG CXXII: The Jailkeeper [Day 1]
DIR By: Le_Shrub
Date: April 9, 2020, 10:25 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: lena link ---
>
> I am still very eh about this lynch. Colts just doesn't look
as scummy as he has when he does play wolf imo - this one seemed
more like an "oh **** I have to come up with reads or else
they'll immediately go after me".
>
--- End Quote ---
This I agree with, but then again that's what most of us are
doing this game imo. We're all trying to contribute as much as
possible but there's almost nothing to talk about so no one
reads as suspicious but Colts and Zech to anyone.
I don't think we have anything better right now though?
I'll lynch Colts.
#Post#: 246--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG CXXII: The Jailkeeper [Day 1]
DIR By: lena
Date: April 9, 2020, 10:26 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: leia link ---
>
> [quote author=lena link=topic=20.msg240#msg240
date=1586444226]
> I am still very eh about this lynch. Colts just doesn't look
as scummy as he has when he does play wolf imo - this one seemed
more like an "oh **** I have to come up with reads or else
they'll immediately go after me".
>
--- End Quote ---
except I count that as wolfy behavior- coming up with a lynch
solely to avoid being lynched. I think there's a difference
between trying to play the game and not be called out for being
passive (which I honestly see more from SuperBoomen), and what
Colts is doing, coming up with a lynch to avoid being lynched.
[/quote]
Was he being lynched before or after his claim? I thought before
it was a lynch on ZechAkari and then he pops in and then people
call him out. I think coming up with a lynch to avoid being
lynched is when there's suspicion already on you and then you
want to throw them off.
What I'm afraid of is that this is turning into what we always
do with Mercury/Rias - lynching them based on suspicious
behavior all the time when that's just how they play the game.
There is also little pushback against this lynch - it's an easy
potential mislynch (or sacrifice, depending on if I'm totally
wrong and he's wolf) for wolves imo.
#Post#: 247--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG CXXII: The Jailkeeper [Day 1]
DIR By: leia
Date: April 9, 2020, 10:39 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: lena link ---
>
> [quote author=leia link=topic=20.msg244#msg244
date=1586445697]
> [quote author=lena link=topic=20.msg240#msg240
date=1586444226]
> I am still very eh about this lynch. Colts just doesn't look
as scummy as he has when he does play wolf imo - this one seemed
more like an "oh **** I have to come up with reads or else
they'll immediately go after me".
>
--- End Quote ---
except I count that as wolfy behavior- coming up with a lynch
solely to avoid being lynched. I think there's a difference
between trying to play the game and not be called out for being
passive (which I honestly see more from SuperBoomen), and what
Colts is doing, coming up with a lynch to avoid being lynched.
[/quote]
Was he being lynched before or after his claim? I thought before
it was a lynch on ZechAkari and then he pops in and then people
call him out. I think coming up with a lynch to avoid being
lynched is when there's suspicion already on you and then you
want to throw them off.
What I'm afraid of is that this is turning into what we always
do with Mercury/Rias - lynching them based on suspicious
behavior all the time when that's just how they play the game.
There is also little pushback against this lynch - it's an easy
potential mislynch (or sacrifice, depending on if I'm totally
wrong and he's wolf) for wolves imo.
[/quote]I believe Vinnie had lynched him to start the game off,
but it wasn't really anything substantial- just a "eh all he's
done is claimed human and I get some sketchy vibes, might as
well push to see where it goes". There were also quite a few
posts worth of people stating why they didn't want to lynch
Zech-
me- "'d lynch Zech to push him for productivity but I don't
think it would work, given that he once had 48 hours as a seer
to defend himself from being lynched and he did not claim seer
once in that 48 hour period, nor did he post anything more than
a few sentences."
kowhai- "don't really get the case against zech, I don't like
the human claiming but we don't even have excess yet, and
nothing about his particular response strikes me as wolfish. no
one is reading wolf to me at all rn, but I might be missing
something."
jess- "Zech since you say you don’t have a life can you at least
give a defense so we don’t lynch an important role? I don’t want
a repeat of the seer thing and you clearly have the time to
defend yourself"
What's weird to me is that Colts comes in after all these points
were made and lynches Zech, and doesn't offer any new arguments
(or arguments period?). I do think you have a good point that we
don't wanna follow a path of behavior based mislynches like with
Rias/Mercury-- however, as I mentioned to Vinnie earlier, based
on the past 3 games, Colts hasn't been the victim of unusual
behavior related deaths.
To your point about not enough opposition, I think that it would
be really valid in a situation where the lynch quickly builds in
half a day- but it's been like 1.5 days, and it was a somehow
slowly building lynch imo. But that's valid, no opposition. Ugh
I really wish he'd come in and defend himself more but idk where
he is.
(Did I answer everything did this make sense I'm typing in the
middle of online class it's so boring)
#Post#: 248--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG CXXII: The Jailkeeper [Day 1]
DIR By: lena
Date: April 9, 2020, 10:49 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Okay, thanks. I'm less dubious going into this lynch now
(Yeah, you answered my questions and it makes sense)
#Post#: 249--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG CXXII: The Jailkeeper [Day 1]
DIR By: ColtsFan18
Date: April 9, 2020, 11:47 am
---------------------------------------------------------
So I'm being lynched and there is probably nothing I can do
about it, but I've been trying to help the town, even if I
didn't do shit. I understand that whatever role I get I usually
play like a wolf, but you need to believe me this time. I am not
a wolf. If you want to lynch me fine, I understand, but lynching
me would be a mistake when there are three other people in this
game who are actually wolves.
#Post#: 250--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG CXXII: The Jailkeeper [Day 1]
DIR By: ColtsFan18
Date: April 9, 2020, 11:49 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: leia link ---
>
> Yeah I'll lynch ColtsFan
>
> Colts, can you point to specific posts where Ziggy's behavior
has been weird? It's clearly not a vibe thing because you
literally said "Zech has been acting weird", so there must be
things that he posted that have lead you to believe it.
>
> to what other people (mainly Vinnie everyone else seems to be
bringing up similar points) have been saying:
> - Cosmic has generally been "blending in" the last few games
anyway though, and afair he hasn't been scum. He just kinda
lurks and is generally reluctant to lynch. Not saying he isn't
scum right now, but just significant to note because as you
said, you are a dirty metagamer
> - ColtsFan hasn't really been suspected in the last two games
because he hasn't been suspicious. Back to Basics, however, he
got lynched on the first day because he was being sketchy. Maybe
I'm missing something, but can you point to him being suspected
by a large portion of players when he wasn't scum?
>
> - also @Avy I could take a Zech being fool/maniac, it would
make sense given the dodgy behavior
>
--- End Quote ---
Youe mean Zech or...
#Post#: 251--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG CXXII: The Jailkeeper [Day 1]
DIR By: emertxEtaKtiK
Date: April 9, 2020, 11:52 am
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: ColtsFan18 link ---
>
> So I'm being lynched and there is probably nothing I can do
about it, but I've been trying to help the town, even if I
didn't do ****. I understand that whatever role I get I usually
play like a wolf, but you need to believe me this time. I am not
a wolf. If you want to lynch me fine, I understand, but lynching
me would be a mistake when there are three other people in this
game who are actually wolves.
>
--- End Quote ---
IDK, seems like quite a defense to me when most people are
considering lynching you and all you do is "I am not a wolf"
without really addressing the arguments against you or
explaining in more detail about your actions.. or even trying to
offer a better counterargument than "I am not a wolf"
#Post#: 252--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG CXXII: The Jailkeeper [Day 1]
DIR By: leia
Date: April 9, 2020, 12:12 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: ColtsFan18 link ---
>
> [quote author=leia link=topic=20.msg223#msg223
date=1586387678]
> Yeah I'll lynch ColtsFan
>
> Colts, can you point to specific posts where Ziggy's behavior
has been weird? It's clearly not a vibe thing because you
literally said "Zech has been acting weird", so there must be
things that he posted that have lead you to believe it.
>
> to what other people (mainly Vinnie everyone else seems to be
bringing up similar points) have been saying:
> - Cosmic has generally been "blending in" the last few games
anyway though, and afair he hasn't been scum. He just kinda
lurks and is generally reluctant to lynch. Not saying he isn't
scum right now, but just significant to note because as you
said, you are a dirty metagamer
> - ColtsFan hasn't really been suspected in the last two games
because he hasn't been suspicious. Back to Basics, however, he
got lynched on the first day because he was being sketchy. Maybe
I'm missing something, but can you point to him being suspected
by a large portion of players when he wasn't scum?
>
> - also @Avy I could take a Zech being fool/maniac, it would
make sense given the dodgy behavior
>
--- End Quote ---
Youe mean Zech or...
[/quote]haha yes I do mean Zech
You should really claim also, you're about to die
#Post#: 253--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG CXXII: The Jailkeeper [Day 1]
DIR By: Vinnie927
Date: April 9, 2020, 12:34 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Wow this day was boring
Need to wait to see how he flips to see what we can learn
#Post#: 254--------------------------------------------------
Re: TWG CXXII: The Jailkeeper [Day 1]
DIR By: ColtsFan18
Date: April 9, 2020, 12:36 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
--- Quote from: leia link ---
>
> [quote author=ColtsFan18 link=topic=20.msg250#msg250
date=1586450988]
> [quote author=leia link=topic=20.msg223#msg223
date=1586387678]
> Yeah I'll lynch ColtsFan
>
> Colts, can you point to specific posts where Ziggy's behavior
has been weird? It's clearly not a vibe thing because you
literally said "Zech has been acting weird", so there must be
things that he posted that have lead you to believe it.
>
> to what other people (mainly Vinnie everyone else seems to be
bringing up similar points) have been saying:
> - Cosmic has generally been "blending in" the last few games
anyway though, and afair he hasn't been scum. He just kinda
lurks and is generally reluctant to lynch. Not saying he isn't
scum right now, but just significant to note because as you
said, you are a dirty metagamer
> - ColtsFan hasn't really been suspected in the last two games
because he hasn't been suspicious. Back to Basics, however, he
got lynched on the first day because he was being sketchy. Maybe
I'm missing something, but can you point to him being suspected
by a large portion of players when he wasn't scum?
>
> - also @Avy I could take a Zech being fool/maniac, it would
make sense given the dodgy behavior
>
--- End Quote ---
Youe mean Zech or...
[/quote]haha yes I do mean Zech
You should really claim also, you're about to die
[/quote]He's ignoring his lynch votes and didn't provide any
form of defense whatsoever.
*****************************************************
Page 12 of 30
DIR Previous Page
DIR Next Page