DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
Mafia Funtimes
HTML https://experimental.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: General Discussion
*****************************************************
#Post#: 412--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: MariaHernandez
Date: December 19, 2014, 10:20 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
You are right cookies. Why would I get another rune going into
my death. Is there a way for me to be saved?
Maybe the water rune isn't the only thing out there that can
save people.
If the rune's destruction is not liked to my death, then how was
is destroyed?
Maybe the people in my group RS can somehow save me overnight?
#Post#: 413--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: MariaHernandez
Date: December 19, 2014, 10:21 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
*linked!
#Post#: 414--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: [[[[[[lllllll]]]]]]]
Date: December 19, 2014, 10:23 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
I'm still not totally convinced Maria is dumb town and that she
could be scum with a neat play to avoid getting lynched, but for
now she's moved up in my power rankings.
I also like the things you are saying this evening,
bar_christina, but you should back it up with a big analysis
post on everyone from yourself if we were to be impressed and
really move up in my rankings.
My opinion on rancho sanza is that they have chimed in with one
big post once, posted an hour after they said they were
rereading to catch up. The next time they checked in and said
they would post, they dropped off without saying anything at
all. It's similar scummy inactivity to target and I figure we
probably don't want to lynch for similar reasons on different
people just because it bit us last time, but it merits
discussion and answers.
#Post#: 415--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: [[[[[[lllllll]]]]]]]
Date: December 19, 2014, 10:32 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
As an aside, I'm refreshing this page pretty consistently and
seeing who's logged in in the last 15 minutes but not saying
anything. Most frequently I see Mr. Diddles, SteveStevenson,
and whatsgoingon. Best case scenario is that they're reading up
and thinking about what's going on, worst case is they're
scum-planning together!
#Post#: 416--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: whatsgoingon
Date: December 19, 2014, 10:33 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Well I just got on and started reading. I'm mostly just face
palming over their conversation right now...
#Post#: 417--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: bar_scotch
Date: December 19, 2014, 10:44 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Cookies-kev, I just got off the train. In the morning, however,
I will sit down and chart rune flow/ player actions.
Whatsgoingon, I will review the last few days, but I will
probably lean a bit on your summaries, since they've been pretty
comprehensive on player actions so far.
#Post#: 418--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: [[[[[[lllllll]]]]]]]
Date: December 19, 2014, 10:55 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Cool stuff, everybody! I'm on a bus for about four and a half
hours tomorrow but I'll be on after 4pm EST.
#Post#: 419--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: SteveStevenson
Date: December 20, 2014, 1:44 am
---------------------------------------------------------
First off, my bad on that post thinking cookies claimed a rune
which he never did. I had gotten that idea on day 2 and clearly
never checked myself, which is stupid.
Also I want to call out cookies again. I haven't been on since I
last posted, so there's no way I was on "but not saying
anything" as he claimed. He said that as an aside as if to point
fingers. It may be true that I showed up online if my browser
kept me logged in? But I don't think that would have been
active. I still have trouble using this to pin cookies as scum,
but I feel like that post by him was a poor excuse to point
fingers at others.
I have had an idea, and I would like to hear responses to it.
You may all think it is stupid. If so, I would really like to
hear why even if it seems blatantly obvious to you. Anyway here
it is:
We may need to get a lynch on mafia today. As someone pointed
out, we could be down three more town by tomorrow. It's possible
this is not entirely correct and that we would still have one
more chance tomorrow, but I'm not positive. Either way, a lot of
the roles and powers seem to come from runes, which rotate daily
as far as I can tell. This would also make me think there is a
rough 1:1 rune to player ratio (but diddles can't hold runes).
There are some anomalies, such as I don't get why the shell got
destroyed if no one died or why the role block on twilight 2.
But, if runes are switching, then there shouldn't be such a
damage to claiming previous possession of them for townies. For
example, I'm on my fourth unique rune now. Let's say we all
claimed our first three runes and the action we pursued with
them (so including last runes that affected last night's
actions). If, as I believe, they have been rotating, there isn't
much damage to this to town because we all have new runes
today/tonight. [If I'm wrong, this whole argument falls apart,
but I'll let someone else tell me why I'm wrong.] It would,
however, tell us what people have been up to and could expose
someone as a liar and scum. If people have powers as part of
their roles, I am not saying they should necessarily expose
themselves. I only suggest the runes since they have switched
and give mafia no information about current rune
possession/power.
I would of course be willing to go first as I proposed this.
However, I realize this idea could be incredibly stupid and give
information to mafia. Maybe I'm making a dumb mistake, but it's
not clear to me how this does so. I would really like feedback
on this idea even if it's "Steve this idea is horrible and you
suck because..." But as we may need to lynch mafia today, this
idea could deliver us a clear shot. Sorry if this is a horrible
idea, but please let me know. I'll ditch and look for scum the
more regular way, but I want a no on this first.
#Post#: 420--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: whatsgoingon
Date: December 20, 2014, 5:07 am
---------------------------------------------------------
Did we ever assume that runes were rotating? Because they're
definitely not. I've lost a rune and gotten it back the same
night, and also lost a rune (didn't say it was broken like
Maria's) and not gotten a replacement.
#Post#: 421--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: [[[[[[lllllll]]]]]]]
Date: December 20, 2014, 7:30 am
---------------------------------------------------------
I agree with you, Steve. We need to out everything and try to
make plays around that information, rather than continue to play
as if this is regular mafia and not some experimental stuff.
I think I would appreciate you leading with the stuff you hinted
at yesterday with your self-protection.
*****************************************************
Page 5 of 31
DIR Previous Page
DIR Next Page