DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
Mafia Funtimes
HTML https://experimental.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: General Discussion
*****************************************************
#Post#: 382--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: whatsgoingon
Date: December 19, 2014, 12:25 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Oh because of the poison. I missed that, sorry. This is weird,
did cookies poison Maria despite sharing that he/she had the
poison rune on day 2? I guess you're normally not notified that
you're poisoned in mafia - I wouldve assumed that if I were in
cookies' situation. But wouldnt an extra kill the next night
have been really suspicious anyways?
Maybe poison is the only way for mafia to kill people? That
doesn't seem likely, although as we say "I wouldn't put it past
Nate".
#Post#: 383--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: MariaHernandez
Date: December 19, 2014, 12:38 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Town read your role descriptions very carefully. I just noticed
that my character is part of a special group RS.
If other people know hat I am talking about, then try using
hints that only others who know would be able to figure out.
We need to somehow figure out the importance of our role names
and other things about our characters.
I believe that this will help us find the mafia because they are
not part of our group.
If we don't lynch me tonight and kill the wrong person, then we
are going to be at the mercy of the mafia in Day 4.
The only town reads I have are Diddles, Steven, BS!
#Post#: 384--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: whatsgoingon
Date: December 19, 2014, 12:47 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Please, entertain me why you have town reads on Diddles, Steve,
and BS.
Also, I'd like to know why you're pointing out town reads but no
suspicions.
For the record I still think Maria is probably town, but I'd
like to make sure.
#Post#: 385--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: Mr. Diddles
Date: December 19, 2014, 2:54 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Man, I wonder why Maria is positive I'm town. Nate wouldn't make
a mafia that has the ability to be revived if successfully
targeted by the town, when town is already at a disadvantage
when trying to find mafia. That's just ridiculous. If I were
truly mafia, I would have voted GU at some point day 1 so that
it wouldn't go to a tie, rather than wasting my revive on the
first day.
I agree with you that I want Maria to explain why she has town
reads on the other two, just don't lump me in with them in terms
of possible suspicion.
Also, does anyone have any thoughts on why there haven't been
direct mafia kills for two nights now?
#Post#: 386--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: whatsgoingon
Date: December 19, 2014, 3:49 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Don't worry Mr. Diddles, you're pretty much confirmed in my
eyes. Diddle onwards.
I just don't understand Maria and wanted to hear her
explanations.
#Post#: 387--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: Allmighty Host
Date: December 19, 2014, 4:01 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Votals:
[1] Cookies: whatsgoingon
Day ends in ~28 hours.
#Post#: 388--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: [[[[[[lllllll]]]]]]]
Date: December 19, 2014, 4:08 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
To come out entirely about the Viper Rune, it notifies the
poisoned target the first time after it is used, so someone
would have said they were poisoned yesterday if they were
poisoned by me. It also said that the poisoned target could be
saved either the night of the poisoning or the night of when it
would come together. Unfortunately, my assumption is that the
water rune would have been the doctor role, as suikosource says
it was used for healing.
Maria, telling everyone to lynch you is the most silly thing
I've heard because we need to use our lynches to actually get
scum, if I were to believe you, which I currently do. I don't
know if we have any chances to get the scum in the night so we
need to lynch correctly. I think this setup gave us two
mislynches at best so we should really shape up from here on
out.
I would really appreciate Maria outing the information she has
obtained during nights and explaining her assuredness when it
comes to what she knows. I still find it scummy that she acts
with certainty that two people were targeted night one (reread
her posts)
I hate to be the person that still casts doubt on the diddler,
but we should consider the fact that he's been a "clear" that's
survived for two nights straight.
#Post#: 389--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: SteveStevenson
Date: December 19, 2014, 4:19 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Diddles, I do believe you're town, but I think the safe way for
town to go for anyone is to always be open to re-evaluating if
new information comes up. It would be an unfair power probably
to let mafia not be lynched. A few pieces of admittedly weak
evidence on you:
-this is an experimental game
-it's not clear to me whether you get one revive only or
infinite
-your role character is mike tyson, who could be more villainous
Now, I don't think this incriminates you at all, and I'm not
advocating going after you. You have played an otherwise team
game and we have the best reason to believe you are town of
anyone for now.
Here are some things about myself and some explanations for what
seems to be going on. My role name is Tommy pickles. Also I've
debated whether there's a downside to giving this information,
but I figure mafia knows this much and they probably know that I
know. I was "hit during the night" but saved. If you guys want
me to explain everything that I know as far as how I was saved,
I will. I think it may be beneficial however to keep mafia
guessing how/why I was. Let me know though.
I have thought about what this information means, but I don't
know why I would be targeted. The best thing I can think of is
that they may have targeted me because it does not give away
much about them. I have targeted ranch, yet to post, and cookies
this game. I stated suspicions of ranch and cookies during day 2
even though I did not end up voting for them in the end.
As for who I think is suspicious now, I'm unsure about Cookies
and Maria. While Cookies was self defensive and those PMs were
certainly suspicious, I'm hesitant to condemn him on that. He
did vote for yet to post. So did I and three others though, so
that's not incriminating in of itself. So I'm suspicious but not
ready to vote him yet.
I don't understand Maria's reasoning for wanting to lynch her
today. Just lynching her and moving on to the next day means we
would be in the same spot tomorrow with two fewer town almost
certainly. She also so far has had a unique style in that she
consistently talks about runes and such. That could be helpful
for town, or it could be distracting and info for mafia. I don't
think this necessarily makes Maria scum. I also don't see a
reason to target her today since she would either die tonight or
be suspicious tomorrow if she survives.
#Post#: 390--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: whatsgoingon
Date: December 19, 2014, 4:43 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
You say that Cookies voting yet to post doesn't really mean
anything, but what about the fact that he was the 4th to vote?
He hard-sealed the deal. SteveStevenson, you were second. So it
wasn't a bandwagon until after you jumped on it (unless you
count my analysis on Yet to post as a vote by me, then you're
the third).
#Post#: 391--------------------------------------------------
Re: Stars of Destiny Mafia Day 3 - Not a Very Peaceful Town
DIR By: SteveStevenson
Date: December 19, 2014, 4:50 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
That is a decent point. I also think that he claimed to have the
same rune (black sword?) yesterday that yet to post had. I will
agree he's suspicious, but I would like to hear more out of him
today before voting on him.
*****************************************************
Page 2 of 31
DIR Previous Page
DIR Next Page