DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       Dumbledore's Army Refugees
  HTML https://darefugees.createaforum.com
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       *****************************************************
   DIR Return to: Deathly Hallows Part I
       *****************************************************
       #Post#: 11690--------------------------------------------------
       "This is the place I was born, I am not returning as someon
       e else"
       By: Russie Stover Date: October 17, 2011, 1:30 am
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       PUNCH IN THE FACE TO J.K ROWLING!
       Anyone remember this?
       #Post#: 11693--------------------------------------------------
       Re: "This is the place I was born, I am not returning as so
       meone else"
       By: Eva Date: October 17, 2011, 1:38 am
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       Well, I remember that line, if that's what you mean?
       #Post#: 11793--------------------------------------------------
       Re: "This is the place I was born, I am not returning as so
       meone else"
       By: StealYellowMen Date: October 17, 2011, 5:06 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       I like that they didn't use polyjuice potion in the movie for
       this scene.
       But when Hermione gets all nervous about being spotted, it
       really bothers me that they don't even discuss the invisibility
       cloak.
       It generally kind of annoys me how the invisibility cloak is
       such a transparent plot device (pun intended). And I get that it
       doesn't film well. I really do. But it bothers me more that they
       don't even really bring it up in the last two films. Like after
       the polyjuice potion wears off in the Ministry and they're left
       completely vulnerable in the atrium. I was like, "DUDE! YOU OWN
       AN INVISIBILITY CLOAK!" I love that scene, and I wouldn't change
       it. But its just something that I can't help but roll my eyes
       at.
       #Post#: 15293--------------------------------------------------
       Re: "This is the place I was born, I am not returning as so
       meone else"
       By: Loony_Gaby Date: November 12, 2011, 8:43 am
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       Yeah, the invisibility cloak was practically ignored in both
       parts. They didn't even mention it was a deathly hallow.
       #Post#: 15907--------------------------------------------------
       Re: "This is the place I was born, I am not returning as so
       meone else"
       By: RaithGyaron Date: November 17, 2011, 7:07 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       [quote author=Russie Stover link=topic=1365.msg11690#msg11690
       date=1318833012]
       PUNCH IN THE FACE TO J.K ROWLING!
       Anyone remember this?
       [/quote]Maybe since I only saw it just once, or the fact that I
       have a poor memory (even though I first watched it today), I
       don't remember it.
       
       [quote author=Loony_Gaby link=topic=1365.msg15293#msg15293
       date=1321108986]
       Yeah, the invisibility cloak was practically ignored in both
       parts. They didn't even mention it was a deathly hallow.
       [/quote]Ollivander did say that one of the Hallows was an
       invisibility cloak when he was telling Harry what they were at
       Shell Cottage.
       [sub][sup]Its weird that I remember that one, but not that the
       other.[/sup][/sub]
       #Post#: 15916--------------------------------------------------
       Re: "This is the place I was born, I am not returning as so
       meone else"
       By: FurySerenity Date: November 17, 2011, 9:20 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       When Xenophilius mentioned the Invisibility Cloak, Hermione
       looks at Ron, as if to say "Could Harry's cloak be a Hallow?!" I
       always saw it like that anyway. A nod to the readers perhaps.
       #Post#: 15917--------------------------------------------------
       Re: "This is the place I was born, I am not returning as so
       meone else"
       By: StealYellowMen Date: November 17, 2011, 9:59 pm
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       Yeah, the readers knew what that look meant. Casual viewers, not
       so much. And while they mentioned the cloak and that a hollow
       was a cloak, they never explicitly said that Harry's cloak was
       THE cloak from the story. Or that Harry had all three hallows
       when he walked into the forest to meet Voldemort.
       *****************************************************