DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       Carrie Brown : Murder In The East River Hotel
  HTML https://carriebrown.createaforum.com
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       *****************************************************
   DIR Return to: Editorials & Essays
       *****************************************************
       #Post#: 4655--------------------------------------------------
       Scenarios In 2025
   DIR By: HowBrown1953
       Date: May 28, 2025, 5:53 am
       ---------------------------------------------------------
       If anyone has anything to add to the following, please do.
       Scenarios Revisited:
       1. Damon's story was true: The room key was left by the farmhand
       in his stable, although he didn't turn the bloody shirt in
       when he filed his affidavits.
       A. Frank the Farmhand was C. Kniclo. He murdered Carrie Brown.
       
       
       B. Frank the Farmhand was C. Kniclo, but he didn't murder
       Carrie Brown.
       Bringing the key home wasn't and isn't proof of him
       committing murder.
       The possibility exists that Eddie Fitzgerald didn't
       actually unlock the door to room 31. While he stated
       he received no answer when he knocked on the door, it is
       possible that he simply went through
       the motions of opening the door, assuming it was locked,
       when he put his key into the door lock. Many
       of us have knocked on a door assuming it was locked while
       we waited for a response. Upon not receiving
       a reply, we placed our key into the door lock and turned
       it, realizing the door was actually open all along.
       2. Damon's story was false. He fabricated a key and made up a
       story. His neighbor chose to
       go along with Damon's subterfuge. His long-time employee,
       Brennan, also agreed to
       participate in the deceit.
       A. In this scenario, Frank the Farmhand wasn't the killer nor
       was he C. Kniclo, but the real C. Kniclo may
       have been the murderer.
       B. On the other hand, C. Kniclo may not have been Brown's
       murderer.
       Damon's story, whether true or false, has no bearing on
       the guilt or innocence of Frank the Farmhand.
       Likewise, Damon's story, whether true or false, has no
       bearing on the guilt or innocence of C. Kniclo.
       
       *****************************************************
       Page 1 of 1