DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
Bookworm Forum
HTML https://bookwormyoutube.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: General Discussion
*****************************************************
#Post#: 42--------------------------------------------------
Re: First Chapter: Major says "REMOVE MAN FROM THE SCENE&qu
ot;
By: Kimberly Perez Date: December 10, 2015, 4:22 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
This is because Major has the idea that the life of animals is
subject to the interests of man. The animals live in misery and
slavery and all because of man, who is the only creature that
consumes without producing. Besides forcing them to work hard
for your benefit.
But I think the decision to get rid of man is not right because
animals and humans are needed to develop.
#Post#: 46--------------------------------------------------
Re: First Chapter: Major says "REMOVE MAN FROM THE SCENE&qu
ot;
By: Eliane20140245 Date: December 12, 2015, 6:17 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
This is because Major thinks that man is the main cause of the
misery and slavery of all the animals. For example, he is who
consumes all the things that the animals produce as milk or
eggs, nevertheless he gives them the bare minimum to survive; or
even, he usually kills them to eat their meat or sell it. For
that reazon, he claims that man is the only real enemy that they
have.
#Post#: 47--------------------------------------------------
Re: First Chapter: Major says "REMOVE MAN FROM THE SCENE&qu
ot;
By: Carolina Jaramillo Date: December 12, 2015, 7:33 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
"Man is only the real enemy we have. Man Removed from the scene,
and the root cause of hunger and overwork is abolished for ever"
this happens because the old Major believes that man is a being
who retains freedom of animals in England and that he only used
these animals for their welfare without giving anything in
return 'Man is the only creature that consume without producin',
because man does not have the ability to get supplies such as
eggs or milk, 'he does not give milk , hedoes not lay eggs, I is
too weak to pull theplough, I can not run fast enough to catch
rabbits. Yet he is lord of all the animals. 'In my opinion, I
think this type of solution is a little out of place, because
the truth is that both animals and humans need each other,
because animals provide supplies that men can not achieve, and
men also give some benefits to the animals who can not get by
themselves.
#Post#: 52--------------------------------------------------
Re: First Chapter: Major says "REMOVE MAN FROM THE SCENE&qu
ot;
By: Mariah Elena Date: December 13, 2015, 7:18 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
I think Mayor feel the inequality between the men and the
animals, especially when the men use the resources of animals to
live, that is why Mayor reflected and said why should the
animals serve to the men? and concluded that the work of the
animals don´t have reason. ;D Ican see in this chapter that
Mayor represent the reflection about the abuse of authority`man
and do the difference for the future generations. :o :o :o
#Post#: 56--------------------------------------------------
Re: First Chapter: Major says "REMOVE MAN FROM THE SCENE&qu
ot;
By: fabrizzio Date: December 13, 2015, 10:00 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
In my opinion, I think that this decision taken by the Mayor is
extreme, because, he intended that the animals have to eradicate
the man, and this is not the best solution; either, by constant
abuse suffered or exploitation that leads to death,but I think
that both are wrong, because they have the wrong concept of the
other. Animals and humans are in the same world because both are
needed; obviously some more than others, or as in the case of
the farmer who abuse these animals. Finally we see that he shows
the real concern; future generations are affected by man.
#Post#: 57--------------------------------------------------
Re: First Chapter: Major says "REMOVE MAN FROM THE SCENE&qu
ot;
By: Alex Juep Date: December 13, 2015, 10:02 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
First, Mayor thinks the man is the main cause of all the
problems of the animals. Given this, Mayor said: "No animal in
England knows the meaning of happiness ... The life of an animal
is misery and slavery ". This means that man exploits animals,
taking advantage of the work that they meet. In my opinion the
decision is not entirely correct, as both, men and animals
depend on each other for their development.
#Post#: 59--------------------------------------------------
Re: First Chapter: Major says "REMOVE MAN FROM THE SCENE&qu
ot;
By: Shakira Malionof Date: December 13, 2015, 10:49 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
The reasons of Major's thinking is due to negative attitudes and
actions of humans in respect to animals; as Mr. Jones, who is
the main cause of suffering of the farm animals, since he used
them just to please his needs, and when the animals no produce
more, he kills them.
I'm agree with Major's position, but I don't think the solution
is dissappearing humans. True, humans need animals, but depend
on each one of us, respect them and value them, since, in
reality, they can't defend themselves.
Remember: "Animals need our help, don't turn them your back"
#Post#: 60--------------------------------------------------
Re: First Chapter: Major says "REMOVE MAN FROM THE SCENE&qu
ot;
By: Celso Huamaní Date: December 14, 2015, 7:21 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
The main reason, I think, was because Major considered that they
(the animals)are only considered like tools by the humans.
Another can be the lack of food ,the poor conditions of life,
the inability to evolve and develop (caused by humans), etc. If
it is true , this attitude can be accepted to a certain extent ,
but also has its wrong side :(. Sometimes, we can see the same
situation in our society, when nobody hear us and we have not
another option that take the justice by our own hands.
#Post#: 67--------------------------------------------------
Re: First Chapter: Major says "REMOVE MAN FROM THE SCENE&qu
ot;
By: Alonso Negreyros Date: December 15, 2015, 9:47 am
---------------------------------------------------------
The most important reason of Major's thinking is due to bad
behavior of farmers (Mr. Jones). In fact, his actions respect
the animals are the cause of the revolution of the farm animals;
starting with abuse of authority against the animals, unkept and
beat up some of them, etc.
This first Chapter is outstanding :) and bring us the message of
caring for the animals because they also have feelings and have
many skills to realize those who want to help.
I'm agree with Major because the animals deserve better care
without abuse or mistreatment. They need someone who gives them
freedom, love and food xD :)
#Post#: 74--------------------------------------------------
Re: First Chapter: Major says "REMOVE MAN FROM THE SCENE&qu
ot;
By: Flopo Date: December 15, 2015, 10:44 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
I think that the main reason is that the life of an animal is
misery and slavery and this is product of bad behavior of
farmers (such as lack of food, the poor living conditions and
abuse of authority against the animals). And as Major said :
"The whole of the produce of our labour is stolen from us by
human beings. (...) Remove Man from the scene, and the root
cause of hunger and overwork is abolished for ever." ;D :D ;D
*****************************************************
DIR Next Page