DIR Return Create A Forum - Home
---------------------------------------------------------
Airbattle Games
HTML https://airbattle.createaforum.com
---------------------------------------------------------
*****************************************************
DIR Return to: IGNORE: Wing Leader Playtest Archive
*****************************************************
#Post#: 2063--------------------------------------------------
Re: O11 Hunters in the Sky
By: pilotofficerprune Date: March 10, 2019, 5:12 am
---------------------------------------------------------
As an FYI, Chris, the DD should have a -2 modifier, as we are
using the Supremacy versions of the DDs rather than the original
Victories counters.
Changes I am adopting:
(1) I’m changing the set up of the Bf 109 sweep to bring it into
the fight more easily.
(2) The Ju 88s can now make glide-bombing attacks.
#Post#: 2078--------------------------------------------------
Re: O11 Hunters in the Sky
By: chief2000 Date: March 10, 2019, 1:27 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Hi Lee!
Yes, I noticed that after I had posted my AAR. I went through
my pieces one by one to make sure that I have the correct ones
based on your list in dropbox. Thanks.
#Post#: 2112--------------------------------------------------
Re: O11 Hunters in the Sky
By: chief2000 Date: March 14, 2019, 1:05 pm
---------------------------------------------------------
Scenario: O11 Hunters in the Sky
Version: v0.3
Playtesters: Chris Bryans (Solo)
Report: This is my third playtest of this scenario. As with
the first two, the victory level was such that did not allow
play of the extension (Germans did not inflict heavy damage on
the airfield again)
Set up: Height error roll unsuccessful for G.I A
Turn One
No tally rolls
Ju-88 begins glide bombing profile on heavy flak
DD3 flak barrage on He111 A and Bf109D B. No effect on He111
Bf-109D B breaks on cohesion roll
Light flak direct fire on Ju88 – no effect
Turn Two
High error rolls on G.I A and B no effect
G.I A tallies Ju52 V and G.I B tallies Ju52 W
Bf109E A and Bf109 I tally G.I A
He111 S enters first barrage square. Cohesion good
He111 S enters second barrage square. Cohesion good
He111T enters first barrage square no effect. No effect in
second barrage square entire
He111 Q enters firsts barrage square and suffers straggler.
Cohesion good
Ju88 U enters barrage square (from DD3) – no effect
Light flak direct fire against Ju88 – no effect
Ju88 U Bomb run: 100% against heavy flak. (boxcars!) 16 hits=
more than triple damage 9 vp.
He111 S bomb run on DD3 2 hits (10% hits)
G.I A vs Bf109E A and I
Bf109s do not score on G.I A but G.I A scores one loss against
Bf109E A
Cohesion: Bf109E A disrupted and Bf109E I breaks (snake eyes!)
G.I A passes cohesion
Dogfight ensues between G.IA and Bf109E A
Turn Three
Hight error G.I L no effect
G.I L tallies Ju52V
Ju88 moves through first barrage square from DD3 – suffers
straggler
Square two barrage rolls cohesion and passes
He111 S enters two barrage squares with no effect
He111 T enters one barrage square and suffers straggler. No
effect from second barrage square
He111 Q enters two barrage squares with no effect
He111 T bomb run on DD3: 10% (2 hits)
He111 Q bomb run on DD3 – 25% (5 hits)
Light flak direct fire vs. Ju52 V nets straggler
Dogfight G.I A vs. Bf109E A. Bf109 suffers two losses and
straggler. No losses on G.I A
Cohesion: both aircraft break
G.I L vs. Ju52 V. Ju52 loses two.
Cohesion: G.I L disrupts. Ju52 V maintains cohesion
G.I B vs. Ju52 W Ju52 W suffers one loss
Cohesion: Ju52 W disrupts; G.I B passes
Turn Four
Light flak direct fire vs. Ju 52 nets one loss
Ju52 W breaks
Ju52 V bomb run: 10% (one hit)
Ju52 W bomb run: 0
G.I L vs Ju52 V no effect on either aircraft
Cohesion disrupts Ju52 V and G.I L passes
G.I B vs Ju52 W no effect on either. Cohesion: G.I B passes
Turn Five
G.I L drops tally on Ju52 V and G.I B drops tally on Ju52 W
G.I L tallies Ju52 Y; G.I B tallies Ju52 Z
Light flak direct fire against Ju52 Y no effect
Ju52 Y bomb run: 0
Ju 52 Z bomb run: 10% One hit
G.I L vs Ju52 Y no effect on either
G.I L breaks
Ju52 Y disrupts
G.I B vs. Ju52 Z: Ju52 suffers three losses and G.I B suffers
none
Cohesion: Both disrupt
Turn Six
G.I B vs. Ju52 Z nets one loss on Ju52 Z with no effect on G.I B
Cohesion: G.I B breaks. Ju52 Z passes
Victory: Germans: 9 hits on DD3 net triple points = 15 vp+9 vp
(triple point damage on heavy flak)+2 vp (airfield)=26 vp
Netherlands: 3 (three Bf109E) + 18 (nine Ju52)=21
21-25=-4. Netherlands victory
Recommendations: My third playtest reaped huge success for the
bombers as they scored triple points for the airfield heavy flak
and the DD3. However, as has been typical in the last three
playtests, they were not able to secure their primary objective
– the airfield. This is the biggest drawback in this scenario.
Without consistent high die rolls, the Germans will never move
onto the second (optional) part of this scenario. To experiment
further, I conducted a simple test:
I rolled for each of the Ju52 four time (equivalent to four
games) and achieved the following results:
This presents a best case scenario in terms of modifiers: no
flak (+1) offsets the -1 for T bombsight at altitude 2. None of
the aircraft are disrupted. Parenthetical numbers are the
numbers of hits for the percentage dropped based on the current
bomb strength of 12.
1
Ju52 V
Ju52 W
Ju52 Y
Ju52 Z
gopher.createaforum.com:70 /forums/airbattle/p/81/1:134: port field too long